What Do You Think Of This Top 20 P4P List ??

[GunStar]

Oh please......Taylor did not take the title from Hops....It was handed to him by a ******ed judge that scored the 12th round that Hopkins clearly won the wrong way.....we've been round and round about this n00b......get your head examined.

It was not a close fight, n00b! Hopkins clearly lost, you can't win the fight by winning the last 3 rounds, that's not how it works.

I had Taylor winning 7 rounds clearly and Hopkins last 3 rounds clearly. round 5 and 9 could've gone either way and I scored both 10-10.

You know I love you, n00b! but some of your judging is way off.

[RAESAAD]

It was not a close fight, n00b! Hopkins clearly lost, you can't win the fight with winning the last 3 rounds, that's not how it works.

I had Taylor winning 7 rounds clearly and Hopkins last 3 rounds clearly. round 5 and 9 could've gone either way and I scored both 10-10.

You know I love you, n00b! but some of your judging is way off.

I love you too sugar but your scoring is off.....There has been many polls on here and other places and more often than not the concensus is that it was a bad decision.....I'll leave it at that. I think a draw would have been fair and appropriate even but Taylor DID NOT win that fight.....He also lost to Winky but thats another story. Taylor should be 25-2-1 assuming Hopkins gave him a remacth after their first fight and taylor took it like I think he did.

[ИATAS]

good list, cant really argue against anything on there. Might have a couple guys swapped, but other than that, no complaints.

[Burning Desire]

I love you too sugar but your scoring is off.....There has been many polls on here and other places and more often than not the concensus is that it was a bad decision.....I'll leave it at that. I think a draw would have been fair and appropriate even but Taylor DID NOT win that fight.....He also lost to Winky but thats another story. Taylor should be 25-2-1 assuming Hopkins gave him a remacth after their first fight and taylor took it like I think he did.

I think Taylor pulled it out, Hopkins done nothing in the first 9 rounds and it was hard to even give him a round because he was so inactive. I had it 7-5 to Taylor, Hopkins won the last 4 clearly but he only has himself to blame for losing the decision based on his inactivity in the early going.

[RAESAAD]

I think Taylor pulled it out, Hopkins done nothing in the first 9 rounds and it was hard to even give him a round because he was so inactive. I had it 7-5 to Taylor, Hopkins won the last 4 clearly but he only has himself to blame for losing the decision based on his inactivity in the early going.

Fair anough way to put it but the actual judges had it worked out so that it would have been a draw but some dumbass judge I think it was Duane Ford if I recall gave the 12th to Taylor......Thats my point. Besides that you have to take the title not get it handed to you generally.

[Burning Desire]

Fair anough way to put it but the actual judges had it worked out so that it would have been a draw but some dumbass judge I think it was Duane Ford if I recall gave the 12th to Taylor......Thats my point. Besides that you have to take the title not get it handed to you generally.

Oh i totally agree with that in fact i wouldn't of been disappointed if it was a draw or Hopkins won it. But IMO from my scoring i really don't think Hopkins done enough in the early going, you know the funny thing is i think Hopkins vs Taylor 2 was just as controversial as the 1st fight because at least Hopkins started a bit faster in the early going, but a lot of people don't agree i guess im only the small percentage of people who think that way.

[GunStar]

I love you too sugar but your scoring is off.....There has been many polls on here and other places and more often than not the concensus is that it was a bad decision.....I'll leave it at that. I think a draw would have been fair and appropriate even but Taylor DID NOT win that fight.....He also lost to Winky but thats another story. Taylor should be 25-2-1 assuming Hopkins gave him a remacth after their first fight and taylor took it like I think he did.

Hopkins lost the ESPN poll, which was the biggest poll.

[RAESAAD]

Oh i totally agree with that in fact i wouldn't of been disappointed if it was a draw or Hopkins won it. But IMO from my scoring i really don't think Hopkins done enough in the early going, you know the funny thing is i think Hopkins vs Taylor 2 was just as controversial as the 1st fight because at least Hopkins started a bit faster in the early going, but a lot of people don't agree im guess im only the small percentage of people who think that way.

I have always felt as close as the second fight was....that it was the right decision. I also agree Hopkins has nobody to blame but himself. I just think it should have been a draw the first time around.

[-Swizzy-]

1 Floyd Mayweather
2 Manny Pacquiao
3 Bernard Hopkins
4 Joe Calzaghe
5 Juan Manuel Marquez
6 Miguel Cotto
7 Israel Vasquez
8 Rafael Marquez
9 Ivan Calderon
10 Juan Diaz
11 Kelly Pavlik
12 Winky Wright
13 Ricky Hatton
14 Joan Guzman
15 Jermain Taylor
16 Shane Mosley
17 Mikkel Kessler
18 Christian Mijares
19 Wladimir Klitschko
20 Chris John

that is the best p4p list that I've ever seen. not perfect, but really good. I just think some ppl should be in different positions and Mijares doesn't belong but besides that, thats pretty much the top p4p guys.

[RAESAAD]

Hopkins lost the ESPN poll, which was the biggest poll.

I hate you...... ****ing NY guido n00bs.....