What Would U say IF Oscar won?

[Fox McCloud]

"Setup" or "overrated" would be the words out of my mouth, depending on what the loss looked like.

[rebmogul]

"Setup" or "overrated" would be the words out of my mouth, depending on what the loss looked like.

another gift. floyd kicks his ass again and easier this time....

[crillz]

honestly dogz it will and thats coming from someone who doesn't really like him in the ring, as a person he gets an A+++ from me but in the ring I seen some shady **** involving him go down. Oscar's legacy would grow and Floyd's will be hurt but not destroyed, it all depends on how he rebounds, he would obviously go for the trilogy but then again this is why this rematch doesn't make sense, why the **** risk fighting this guy and making him look better than what he really is by being there with you despite his current standings all for money? if he didn't care about his legacy and making history or being great he would have vacated the belts and went down to 140 then back to 147 then a catch weight against a Lightweight and things of such but that isn't the case, he isn't weight jumping and still holds the crown so to even allow a chance for him to lose his crown in a rematch against someone who didn't deserve to be in there with him in the first place is absurd..

I respect the **** out of Floyd but this decision was dumb.. to answer your question, will this help his legacy? hell yea, but too bad it will be a fight the he doesn't rightfully deserve.. Stevie Forbes with all due respect for him, he is a good guy and I actually like his fights but he is NO qualifying opponent to face Floyd for the title at Welterweight in a rematch when guys like Cotto, Margarito, Cintron, Williams, Mosley and Clottey are walking around waiting. even at Middleweight Oscar had to take on Sturm to qualify for Hopkins and even in defeat he stole the win to preserve his showdown, wht if Forbes wins and Oscar robs him too? it helps his legacy but not his credibility because while yes you've beaten Floyd NO you didn't deserve the fight and due to your account balance you stopped other legendary fights with legitimately ranked contenders that the fans wanted to see just to butter your own ass and save your face undeservingly.. a no no in my book.