Best Judge

[PBF Mayweather]

Who do you guys think is the best judge? Jerry Roth seems to be solid.

Who is the worst?

[BiggyGuns91]

Who do you guys think is the best judge? Jerry Roth seems to be solid.

Who is the worst?

the two who had casamayor beating santa cruz

[miron_lang]

Judges above 70 usually always had it the other way around.

[Fox McCloud]

Best: I don't know... I've yet to see a judge do well in all his fights.

Worst: Tony Paolilo... widest score in Forrest-Quartey, and was the one who scored it for Santa Cruz, although he was clearly in on the fix with a 114-113 scorecard.

Honorable mention for worst: Glen Hamada, Harold Lederman, Julie Lederman.

[robjr]

best judges..

Glen Hamada
Duane Ford



Worst

Mike Glienna
Paul Smith
Dave Moretti
Chuck Giampa
Tony Paolillo
Melvina Lathan
Steve Weisfeld
Chuck Hassett
David Mendoza

all I can come up with for now..

[Fox McCloud]

Lol, robjr, I really do have a reason to give you **** this time...

Who knew that you would call the guy (Hamada) who had Jones-Tarver I 9 rounds to 3 for Jones one of the best judges?

[robjr]

Lol, robjr, I really do have a reason to give you **** this time...

Who knew that you would call the guy (Hamada) who had Jones-Tarver I 9 rounds to 3 for Jones one of the best judges?

whoa!! you actually thought i dug up that info.. sometimes u give me too much credit as a RJJ fan...

what bad things did hamada do?

[Fox McCloud]

whoa!! you actually thought i dug up that info.. sometimes u give me too much credit as a RJJ fan...

what bad things did hamada do?

The two scorecards I remember from Hamada are:

Jones-Tarver I: 117-111 Jones (ri-****ing-diculous)
Mayweather-Judah: 119-109 Mayweather (also ri-****ing-diculous)

Does this guy even watch the fights?

[robjr]

some more bad ones..

Robert Byrd
John Duggan

and any judge that scored a decision in any big fight for ottke in favor of him.. lol

[robjr]

The two scorecards I remember from Hamada are:

Jones-Tarver I: 117-111 Jones (ri-****ing-diculous)
Mayweather-Judah: 119-109 Mayweather (also ri-****ing-diculous)

Does this guy even watch the fights?

whoa he scored that for mayweather? sick