McGirt: "Oscar Is #3 P4P Because He's The Only One Who Really Tested Floyd"

[Addison]

Buddy McGirt's P4P Rankings

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Bernard Hopkins
3. Oscar De La Hoya
4. Manny Pacquiao
5. Juan Manual Marquez
6. Joe Calzaghe
7. Miguel Cotto
8. Israel Vaquez
9. Rafael Marquez
10. Juan Diaz

"Floyd is the best fighter in the world because he's beaten everyone. He beat Zab, and he actually had a tougher time with Carlos Baldomir than he did with Ricky Hatton, in my opinion. Hatton is very overrated, I think. I put Bernard Hopkins up there because he's beaten the best, and he's been in with the best. He stepped up two weight classes to beat Tarver when no one thought he could. You gotta put him in there. Oscar I put at three because he's the only one who really tested Floyd. Oscar really took Floyd to the well. I put Pacquiao below them because he beat two guys near the end, Erik Morales and Marco Antonio Barrera."

Buddy McGirt, The Ring Magazine, April 2008

[Horus]

Ring Mag...

Dont do this to yourself.......

People are going to think that This Mag is a Joke now...

[Silencers]

I disagree with that list. DLH shouldn't be there other than that he's got the right fighters in the wrong positions.

[Darkstar]

I kinda like it. Its a funny way to look at it. But I know its wrong.

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

Well, I know everyone hates Oscar but IMO he's never lost the first half of any fight. If he had better stamina, he'd be a great fighter. Maybe a gay one, but a great one. lol

[WLAD OWNS]

Buddy McGirt, The Ring Magazine, April 2008

Who cares what Buddy McGirt says? He is a mediocre trainer and he has no credibilty. I knew Buddy was ******, but he has proven that he is ******ED calling Oscar the #3 p4p fighter.

[Piggu]

That's........... interesting.

[Liaison]

Ahh, **** it, Corley, Chavez & Augustus make my top 10 of the 21st century because they tested Floyd.

[Fox McCloud]

Who cares what Buddy McGirt says? He is a mediocre trainer and is has no credibilty. I knew Buddy was ******, but he has proven that he is ******ED calling Oscar the #3 p4p fighter.

****** comment. McGirt is one of the best, considering the results he gets with the B-level fighters that Steward doesn't want.

Anyways, the criteria for ranking Oscar at #3 is so dumb... so ****ing dumb.

Apparantly the previous losses, and inactivity don't matter because he looked good in a loss? That is unforgivable.

[WLAD OWNS]

****** comment. McGirt is one of the best, considering the results he gets with the B-level fighters that Steward doesn't want.

Anyways, the criteria for ranking Oscar at #3 is so dumb... so ****ing dumb.

Apparantly the previous losses, and inactivity don't matter because he looked good in a loss? That is unforgivable.

You have to be kidding me...he is very overrated and his record as a trainer is mediocre. Please don't mention McGirt in the same sentence as Steward again...Steward>>>>McGirt.