Who is better Oscar or Margarito?

[Haterfree]

I think the answer to this question is Obvious. Oscar has more victories, has held more titles, & has a superior resume. But the reason why I ask this question is because some of the haters claim that Floyd is fighting a lesser caliber fighter by fighting Oscar later on this year.

I wouldnt mind seeing Floyd beat on a former titleholder with 5 losses like Margarito. But in the end it does nothing for his legacy. Because once he beats Margarito the haters will claim that Margarito was just an overhyped former champion. But beating Oscar twice does alot more for any fighters legacy.
Is there anyone who actually thinks that Margarito is better than Oscar?

[Slotff]

Oscar>>>>>>>>>>>>Margarito

[Calzaghe-Fan]

I think

in 2008

Margarito beats Oscar

[Slotff]

I think

in 2008

Margarito beats Oscar

Why?

Even old Oscar gave the best fighter on earth alot of trouble. You are entitled to your opinion, but what is your reasoning?

[Calzaghe-Fan]

Oscar never gave Floyd no trouble. He was active in the opening rounds but Mayweather knew what he was doing. He slowly picked him off and cautiously won the fight. I've been a big fan of Margarito's fighting style for a while now and from what I've seen he can definently beat Oscar.

Guess what Im saying is I think Margarito can do damage to any of the top welters, he just couldnt handle Williams' reach.

[2501]

oh haters, when will you ever learn!

[TopDawg]

Oscar, he can brawl, and box.

[Scott9945]

Oscar has the better resume and credentials, but in 2008 Margarito is the tougher opponent.

[Haterfree]

Oscar has the better resume and credentials, but in 2008 Margarito is the tougher opponent.

I cant tell the future but Oscar DOES have the better resume & credentials.

[Horus]

I think

in 2008

Margarito beats Oscar

BASED ON WHAT..????


Golden Schlog...


DAMN I never thought somebody would say this....?


UR really are a Fan of Margarito...