Floyd vs Hatton : Opposition Comparison

[Crazylegs77]

---------TW--TL--TD-(Wins Loss Draws Total of all Opponents)
Hatton- 978-392-65
Floyd- 1008-181-35

Thought Id test my theory of using overall competition level to compare fighters..Floyd clearly faced better opposition compared to Hatton.

[HotSizzle]

---------TW--TL--TD-(Wins Loss Draws Total of all Opponents)
Hatton- 978-392-65
Floyd- 1008-181-35

Thought Id test my theory of using overall competition level to compare fighters..Floyd clearly faced better opposition compared to Hatton.

and..........

[Crazylegs77]

and..........

Earlier I posted a comparison between Hopkins and Calzaghe.
Some said it didnt matter what the numbers turned out to be, so I wanted to compare a fight that happened already. My apologies for thinking.

[Jim Jeffries]

At 38-0, Ricky Hatton had never won a major world title in his life.

At 38-0, Floyd was a 6 time world champ in 5 different weight divisions.

But according to you, they were equal in magnitude when you are adding up numbers trying to find some meaning.

Of course Floyd has beaten better overall opposition to this point, but you sure as hell can't determine that by adding up numbers of wins and losses of their opponents.

[Crazylegs77]

At 38-0, Ricky Hatton had never won a major world title in his life.

At 38-0, Floyd was a 6 time world champ in 5 different weight divisions.

But according to you, they were equal in magnitude when you are adding up numbers trying to find some meaning.

Of course Floyd has beaten better overall opposition to this point, but you sure as hell can't determine that by adding up numbers of wins and losses of their opponents.

I just did it. Just looking at the numbers shows Floyds superiority.