Who will retire Undefeated from these Two?

[Parody]

dont forget about Hopkins

Hopkins in 90 man...he has 5% chance of winning

[Ironside]

Good thread, I chose both, that's assuming they retire when I want them to. Calzaghe will beat Hopkins IMO, then he should fight 1 or 2 more fights, but none of the upcoming hungry guys like Dawson or Pavlik, I think he would lose. While PBF should fight Cotto and maybe end his career with a big payday rematch with DLH. Some fighters never know when to quit though.

[Scott9945]

Calzaghe only has about two fights left. No matter what he says he'll do, Floyd can still fight for years because he is so much younger.

[SkillspayBills]

Both. They only have 1 or 2 bouts left in them and they can come out victorious in both.

[Silencers]

Both. Calzaghe has 2 or 3 fights left and I don't think he'll lose those. Mayweather also has only 2 or 3 fights left and if he stays away from Williams, he'll go undefeated.

[Panamaniac]

Neither. Although PBF is more likely to do so, if he limits his next fights to just three. If he sticks around for, say, ten, the law of averages will eventually catch-up to him. Calzaghe will lose within three. Don't ask me for scientific reasons to support my claim... It's just a ****ing hunch.

[Dick-Sucker]

Floyd Mayweather or Joe Calzaghe?

Both Mayweather Beats Cotto UD (6 rounds), Williams UD ( 2 rounds), Margarito ( UD 8 rounds).

Calzaghe beats Hopkins UD (6 Rounds), Dawson (UD) 8 rounds), Mundine (UD 3 rounds).