Bigger accomplishment?

[El Dominicano]

Joe Calzaghe beating Lacy/Kessler
or
Joan Guzman beating Barriors/Soto?

The reason I ask this is because many put Joe Calzaghe 3rd P4P list when I feel that Joan has done more. Joan is looking to fight the best. Guzman has called out Pacman/JMM and Valero. Joe fought bums and is looking to take a bite off of an old B-Hop's Legacy. I'm a huge Guzman fan but even I dont put him in the 3rd P4P list. And thats why I ask whats a better accomplishment beat Lacy/Kessler or beating Soto/Barriors P4P

Top 10
1. PBF
2. Pacman
3. B-Hop
4. Winky Wright
5. Kelly Pavlik
6. Miguel Cotto
7. JMM
8. Joan Guzman
9. Baby Bull
10. Paul Williams

[flat1985]

Joe Calzaghe beating Lacy/Kessler
or
Joan Guzman beating Barriors/Soto?

The reason I ask this is because many put Joe Calzaghe 3rd P4P list when I feel that Joan has done more. Joan is looking to fight the best. Guzman has called out Pacman/JMM and Valero. Joe fought bums and is looking to take a bite off of an old B-Hop's Legacy. I'm a huge Guzman fan but even I dont put him in the 3rd P4P list. And thats why I ask whats a better accomplishment beat Lacy/Kessler or beating Soto/Barriors P4P

Top 10
1. PBF
2. Pacman
3. B-Hop
4. Winky Wright
5. Kelly Pavlik
6. Miguel Cotto
7. JMM
8. Joan Guzman
9. Baby Bull
10. Paul Williams

How can they be in it but not Calzaghe?

[eazy_mas]

I going with Calzaghe because he unified the title and beaten the best in that division while Guzman beat one of the best but not the best

[El Dominicano]

How can they be in it but not Calzaghe?

Because they have done way more then Calzaghe.

[flat1985]

Because they have done way more then Calzaghe.

Like what????

[El Dominicano]

Like what????

LOL I can't believe u go as far as to ask this.

[The Wire]

Because they have done way more then Calzaghe.

What the **** has Paul Williams done!?! Margarito is no better than Brewer, Mitchell or Eubank and certainly no better than Lacy (before Calzaghe ruined him) or Kessler. Just another hater thread, booooooooooring

[Dynamite Kid]

well Barrios & Lacy were outboxed LOL

[RichCCFC]

Hater thread, get the **** outta here.

Joan Guzman isn't even a top 3 Super Featherweight or top 30 P4P, go find another boy.

[flat1985]

LOL I can't believe u go as far as to ask this.

Your yankey friend is gonna get the beatdown on April 12th