Who has the better legacy right now?

[GunStar]

I will help you, it was 2001

Hahaha.

[wmute]

Tito is not a true middleweight.

Ahem, too bad he did not weigh less than 160 since fighting Vargas in 2000.

RJ was also a small LHW.

Big difference is he lost at 35. Tito lost at 28.

[Parody]

At 160 - Hopkins
at 168 - Toney
at 175 - McCallum, Hill, Woods, Tarver
Above 175 - John Ruiz

[GunStar]

I'm surprised you didn't add Virgill Hill or Mike McCallum in Roy's list.

Dude, if you're going to count McCallum then Jopey fans should count the Duran win too.

[wmute]

Titos actually got the better names on his record,win lose or draw

Pernell Whitaker
Oscar De La Hoya
Fernando Vargas
Bernard Hopkins
Ricardo Mayorga
Winky Wright

Roys got :
Antonio Tarver
Glen Johnson
John Ruiz
Clinton Woods
Hopkins
Toney

In terms of legacy,Roy did more,won titles at different weight classes

Add McCallum and Hill for Jones.

[GunStar]

Ahem, too bad he did not weigh less than 160 since fighting Vargas in 2000.

RJ was also a small LHW.

Big difference is he lost at 35. Tito lost at 28.

The point is Tito was never a true middleweight, so I don't care if he was 28 or 15.

[Parody]

Dude, if you're going to count McCallum then Jopey fans should count the Duran win too.

Well since bishop added Whitaker on Trinidad's list I added McCallum

and after McCallum got dominated by Jones Jr he gave James Toney a tough fight which Toney won close.

[wmute]

Dude, if you're going to count McCallum then Jopey fans should count the Duran win too.

If Pea is on Tito's list anything can be added to any list. Leonard on Camacho's and so on...

[GunStar]

At 160 - Hopkins
at 168 - Toney
at 175 - McCallum, Hill, Woods, Tarver
Above 175 - John Ruiz

Considering that Jones spent most of his career at 175, that's not very good. Considering McCallum was 100 and many had Tarver winning all 3 fights.

[BrooklynBomber]

You mean retire??

As in quit boxing.