2008 Pound For Pound Top 10 Ring Magazine

[Flab]

Calzaghe
Kessler
Bute
Mundine
Froch

Just because they aren't American doesn't mean it's not a tough division.

And Calzaghe has only fought one of these guys.

[Ironside]

And Calzaghe has only fought one of these guys.

Kessler is by far the best one on that list, you can't deny that.

[Konstantin]

Calzaggie should be higher, Bhop should be lower and Hatton shouldnt even be on the list.

[Flab]

Calzaghe
Kessler
Bute
Mundine
Froch

Just because they aren't American doesn't mean it's not a tough division.

I find it funny how people disown a boxer who got ktfo. The pinoys will be saying pacman is Japanese after Marquez isfinished with him

[moy22487]

calderon for hatton
move Cal to number 3 and move every body down one to fill that space.
vazquez down to nine and cotto to his spot. (vazquez is lower in my list because all tho he did win a great fight he had lost the first one)

[NeXt In Line]

Calzaghe should be # 2, Pavlik should be in there somewhere, Ricky shouldn't even be on the list anymore, least not Top 10. I see it like this:

1. Floyd
2. Calzaghe
3. Pac-Man
4. JMM
5. Hopkins
6. Vazquez
7. Cotto
8. Pavlik
9. Rafael Marquez
10. Winky

I for one think Wink still deserves to be in the P4P list.

[revs1227]

list isnt bad id put calz in hopkins place and pavlik in calz n take hopkins out lol ..hatton and winky are good

[Boxingwizard]

Calzaghe should be # 2, Pavlik should be in there somewhere, Ricky shouldn't even be on the list anymore, least not Top 10. I see it like this:

Hatton deserves to be more on that list than Winky. Winky hasn't done ****.

[Dick-Sucker]

Kessler is by far the best one on that list, you can't deny that.

Kessler is the best on records. But i seriously think Mundine has become a complete fighter. As seen by his Green and Soliman demolitions. Even though there not the best fighters in the world or up to many peoples defintion of world class, Mundine put on exhibitions of speed, power and perfect defensive skills on both of those nights. I think a rematch with Kessler Mundine could win by a UD. But he could also loose if he turns up scared and non-agressive. Im a firm believer that styles make fights, and Mundine is technically the best fighter Joe has ever fought, if they fought. And thats why i think it will be the toughest fight of Joe's career.

Sure these are big statements. But i can see a late bloomer when its in front of me. And he is one.

[Flab]

Kessler is the best on records. But i seriously think Mundine has become a complete fighter. As seen by his Green and Soliman demolitions. Even though there not the best fighters in the world or up to many peoples defintion of world class, Mundine put on exhibitions of speed, power and perfect defensive skills on both of those nights. I think a rematch with Kessler Mundine could win by a UD. But he could also loose if he turns up scared and non-agressive. Im a firm believer that styles make fights, and Mundine is technically the best fighter Joe has ever fought, if they fought. And thats why i think it will be the toughest fight of Joe's career.

Sure these are big statements. But i can see a late bloomer when its in front of me. And he is one.

Mudine should be striped of his title, he fights nobodies in world title fights, I totally disagree with everything you said.