The 10 Judges and 3 Refs Movement

[Dick-Sucker]

The Official Ten Judges and 3 refs Thread.

Ten Judges Per fight :

- Costs more
- Reduces the chances of corruption
- Leads to more accurate scoring
- Shows those bias and corrupt judges

3 Refs :

- Similar to MMA
- Allows 2 outside refs to inform inside ref, about possible things that are happening and that he can't see. Stops the ref vision from being limited inside the ring.

Final Plan : When judges scorecards are being announced. They are announced slow and judges faces are put on the big screen.

My Plan : Im creating a website for this movement. Im willing to put thousands of dollars into it, to make sure our sport improves. We lack legitimacy, by poor judging and fights where the winner is already decided before the actual fight starts.

(We will edit a few provisions as the movement progresses). Just say im in, acts as a signature.

[SkillspayBills]

The Official Ten Judges and 3 refs Thread.

Ten Judges Per fight :

- Costs more
- Reduces the chances of corruption
- Leads to more accurate scoring
- Shows those bias and corrupt judges

3 Refs :

- Similar to MMA
- Allows 2 outside refs to inform inside ref, about possible things that are happening and that he can't see. Stops the ref vision from being limited inside the ring.

Final Plan : When judges scorecards are being announced. They are announced slow and judges faces are put on the big screen.
My Plan : Im creating a website for this movement. Im willing to put thousands of dollars into it, to make sure our sport improves. We lack legitimacy, by poor judging and fights where the winner is already decided before the actual fight starts.

(We will edit a few provisions as the movement progresses). Just say im in, acts as a signature.

Lmao I found that part completely hilarious. If it was a bogus decision that judge would be hunted like cattle and everyone would know how he/she looks.

[Dick-Sucker]

Lmao I found that part completely hilarious. If it was a bogus decision that judge would be hunted like cattle and everyone would know how he/she looks.

Exactly my point. Its gonna work aswell. Im sick of this judging ****. Lets all get on this movement.

E.G Mundine vs Kessler. 116-111. And then some random scores it 120-108. I want that guy who scored every round to Kesslers head on the television screen in the middle of the sydney entertainment center.

[eazy_mas]

I dont think it practical.

Judges are given some course in how to judge a fight as well as it pretty hard for the normal boxing fan to understand.

I think another good way is the Judges should be writing notes on why he gave this round to this fight and why not to another fighter

[Dick-Sucker]

I dont think it practical.

Judges are given some course in how to judge a fight as well as it pretty hard for the normal boxing fan to understand.

I think another good way is the Judges should be writing notes on why he gave this round to this fight and why not to another fighter

they should have to write down why. And then its reviewed by a judging commissioner after the fight.

And there should be ten judgs all different ringside positions. And i want there faces up on the screens. They will get cheered for every good score, and booed for bad ones. Mostly the crowds are very good judges. (except for De La Hoya vs Sturm)

[robjr]

Lmao I found that part completely hilarious. If it was a bogus decision that judge would be hunted like cattle and everyone would know how he/she looks.

hahaha same..

so true though..

[eazy_mas]

they should have to write down why. And then its reviewed by a judging commissioner after the fight.

And there should be ten judgs all different ringside positions. And i want there faces up on the screens. They will get cheered for every good score, and booed for bad ones. Mostly the crowds are very good judges. (except for De La Hoya vs Sturm)

but for example what if the fighter is virtually unknowen beaten the hometown hero?

what if boxing big boys have something planed for this fighter like Oscar?

many of the boxing judges are doing it as a part time job and have respectable jobs outside boxing.

There is many things will make it not practical maybe 3 ref is good but 10 judges is not

[Dick-Sucker]

but for example what if the fighter is virtually unknowen beaten the hometown hero?

what if boxing big boys have something planed for this fighter like Oscar?

many of the boxing judges are doing it as a part time job and have respectable jobs outside boxing.

There is many things will make it not practical maybe 3 ref is good but 10 judges is not

Well it would be pretty obvious for other boxing fans to see its just a bias crowd booing the judge. And the judges would know that to. E.G As we all know the judges were wrong scoring the De La Hoya vs Sturm, and the fans were wrong. Its easy for us to tell. But in a majority of cases the crowds reactions will be honest.

Even if there part time. There still being paid. And if they can't do it half decent, then they deserve to be shown on the big screen.

Just watched mayweather vs castillo, made my blood boil

[eazy_mas]

Well it would be pretty obvious for other boxing fans to see its just a bias crowd booing the judge. And the judges would know that to. E.G As we all know the judges were wrong scoring the De La Hoya vs Sturm, and the fans were wrong. Its easy for us to tell. But in a majority of cases the crowds reactions will be honest.

Even if there part time. There still being paid. And if they can't do it half decent, then they deserve to be shown on the big screen.

Just watched mayweather vs castillo, made my blood boil

well for example Castillo vs Mayweather it was a close fight but many still think Castillo won but I though there was 4 close round which makes a big difference in scoring.

Not everyone understand judging. There are certain people looking for certain things.

[Dick-Sucker]

well for example Castillo vs Mayweather it was a close fight but many still think Castillo won but I though there was 4 close round which makes a big difference in scoring.

Not everyone understand judging. There are certain people looking for certain things.

But as a whole. Its going to make corruption and poor judging less frequent and likely.

Sure where going to have bias crowds booing good judges. But its easy for us to tell when this happens.

Mate. Castillo was seriously robbed. Sure there were close rounds. Then they should have called it a draw then.

Boxing needs legitimacy.