hatton still on your p4p list?

[boxing_pundit85]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_Magazine_pound_for_pound

imo he is a good fighter, nothing more. he will have 3 or 4 losses in no time if he continues to fight good comp at 140 and deff at 147. he aint on mine, is he on yours. and do you read into oscars mag ranking him there because oscar may want to fight him?

[revs1227]

no i got him at 9 or 10 ...

[Njord777]

Juan Urango? Luis Collazo? A loss to Mayweather? No. Fighting unimpressive offense to set-up a shot with the top dog, and getting knocked out, is not going to get you on my pound for pound list. You have too many people who have been fighting better opposition, or simply not losing-

1.) Floyd Mayweather
2.) Manny Pacquiao
3.) Joe Calzaghe
4.) Miguel Cotto
5.) Isreal Vazquez
6.) Kelly Pavlik
7.) Juan Manuel Marquez
8.) Bernard Hopkins
9.) Rafeal Marquez
10.) Juan Diaz

Yes, I can see people debating my list- but I'm more than willing to give my logic. Don't kill me if you disagree; it might not be perfect but it's far from the worst I've seen.

[MELLY-MEL...]

nah, i love ricky, but he never is making my list.

[TheGreatA]

Top 20.
If he starts dominating the LWW division again he might still get back to top 10. There are some good fighters to fight for Hatton. Malignaggi, Witter and Torres.

[TopDawg]

As a matter of fact, yes he is.

[Sweet Pea 50]

Juan Urango? Luis Collazo? A loss to Mayweather? No. Fighting unimpressive offense to set-up a shot with the top dog, and getting knocked out, is not going to get you on my pound for pound list. You have too many people who have been fighting better opposition, or simply not losing-

1.) Floyd Mayweather
2.) Manny Pacquiao
3.) Joe Calzaghe
4.) Miguel Cotto
5.) Isreal Vazquez
6.) Kelly Pavlik
7.) Juan Manuel Marquez
8.) Bernard Hopkins
9.) Rafeal Marquez
10.) Juan Diaz

Yes, I can see people debating my list- but I'm more than willing to give my logic. Don't kill me if you disagree; it might not be perfect but it's far from the worst I've seen.

Naw man, thats a pretty solid list in my eyes. If anybody gives you **** about it, they are just wasting their breath, because its YOUR list, nawmean? **** what anybody has to say about it.

[Njord777]

Naw man, thats a pretty solid list in my eyes. If anybody gives you **** about it, they are just wasting their breath, because its YOUR list, nawmean? **** what anybody has to say about it.

Thanks, man. Yeah, I mean...the main debate I see is some people don't think Baby Bull is top ten yet...Marquez is a tad low...some people would debate him being behind Hopkins, but like you said- it's just the way I see it.

The key is: no. Ricky Hatton does not make the cut. Somebody would have to get snubbed for him to be in the top 10.

[Sweet Pea 50]

Thanks, man. Yeah, I mean...the main debate I see is some people don't think Baby Bull is top ten yet...Marquez is a tad low...some people would debate him being behind Hopkins, but like you said- it's just the way I see it.

The key is: no. Ricky Hatton does not make the cut. Somebody would have to get snubbed for him to be in the top 10.

No problem.
The list you have is pretty dead on in my eyes. You might switch a fighters posistion here or there, but thats just semantics.
And I still like Hatton. But top 10? Naw...

[Welter_Skelter]

He never made my list...