What boxer could be the best in 3 divisions right now other than Floyd??

[nmuburner22]

Floyd unarguably is the man at 147 and 154 and would go back down and own 140 as well.

What other boxer could do that in his respective divisions???



I would say Calzaghe...I think he could do good at 160, 168 and 175.

[revs1227]

hatton floyd at 140 would be fun .....i dnt think floyd can take 154 ..he beat de la goya ! winky vs floyd 154 winky ud who knows were winkts goin next thow ..also i think cotto n williams are ahead of floyd in the 147 rankins ..calz i agree on that he can prolly ud pavlik n jermain ..would love 2 see him fite them and at 175 chad dawson would be tough 4 calz but he can prolly come of with the decision.... maybe pac man in his 2 closest weight classes .

[nmuburner22]

hatton floyd at 140 would be fun .....i dnt think floyd can take 154 ..he beat de la goya ! winky vs floyd 154 winky ud who knows were winkts goin next thow ..also i think cotto n williams are ahead of floyd in the 147 rankins ..calz i agree on that he can prolly ud pavlik n jermain ..would love 2 see him fite them and at 175 chad dawson would be tough 4 calz but he can prolly come of with the decision.... maybe pac man in his 2 closest weight classes .

how can cotto an williams be better than floyd when he is the number one fighter in the sport

[Fox McCloud]

I'm not really sure what Floyd did to become THE MAN at 154 to be honest.

He won an ABC belt from the guy ranked #3 by the ring.

Impressive victory, but not enough to take control of the division.

[nmuburner22]

I'm not really sure what Floyd did to become THE MAN at 154 to be honest.

He won an ABC belt from the guy ranked #3 by the ring.

Impressive victory, but not enough to take control of the division.

Oscar at 154 is the best fighter in that division.

[Fox McCloud]

Oscar at 154 is the best fighter in that division.

That is an argument to be made.

There are plenty of counterarguments that can be made, such as Spinks, Forrest or Karmazin.

Point is, there is no definitive best at 154.

[nmuburner22]

That is an argument to be made.

There are plenty of counterarguments that can be made, such as Spinks, Forrest or Karmazin.

Point is, there is no definitive best at 154.

can we stick to thread please....

[revs1227]

Oscar at 154 is the best fighter in that division.

haha no he is not !.....how did he get that rank from beating mayorga! lmao ..spkins would ud the **** outta de la hoya ..and i hatee spinks .... floyd hasnt fought the proper contenders at 147 2 be #1 in that division ..ther4 williams and cottos should rightfully be ahead of him in the rankings at 147

[revs1227]

mosley n zab >carlos baldomir and zab

[Thread Stealer]

calzaghe couldn't make 160 as he has a tough time making 168 as it is. i think he'd beat the 160 lb. champ pavlik if pavlik moved up though.

calzaghe would probably beat 175 lb. ring champ old man river hopkins, and linear 175 lb. champ zsolt "avoid any contender with a pulse" erdei, but i think chad dawson would beat calzaghe.