Who's the better fighter and why?

[C'MONMANG']

Floyd or Shane.please explain why you feel each one of them is currently the better fighter based on their competition or lack there of .

[Lucky13]

Shane has fought the tougher guys but at this point, I think Floyd is the better fighter.

[wmute]

Shane cannot adapt. Except a little bit for Winky 2. Mayweather is a fox. That's what there is to it, Shane blend of speed and power, his offensive frame of mind sure look great, but they sure dont make him the greater fighter.

[Dorian]

are we talking about primes here?

[nmuburner22]

Shane has fought better comp.........Floyd is the better fighter.

simple.

[FIGHTING_FLIP]

floyd is the greater fighter..mosley may have speed and power with great heart, but what sperates them is floyds ring smarts, how he can adapt,how he capitalizes on mistakes so quickly..only the greatest fighters could do that (muhammad ali and ray robinson)

[Dorian]

Shane had more power but he didn't have the reflexes floyd has

[AntonTheMeh]

shane was a lightweight roy jones.floyd is better and has always been defensively.he's more complete.prime i take shane though.

[nmuburner22]

Shane had more power but he didn't have the reflexes floyd has

or defense.

[BROOKLYN CESAR]

I think floyd might have the edge but Shane is the man!!! You cant not like someone who always comes to fight and doesnt talk **** about the person he is in with!!!

But on the other hand you cant deny that floyd is the man to beat right now in boxing!!!

Floyds def is the big difference here its much better then shanes and i think he might be a little bit quicker as well!!! shane didnt look as quick as he use to in his last bout!!!