WHO DOES MAYWEATHER HAVE TO BEAT(again)to SERIOUSLY EARN YOUR RESPECT& Be called ATG?

[evanobando]

Mayweather is still undefeated....I respect that.. 39 fight still unbeaten.. Few hall of famers in it.. 17+ of champions... A few big undefeated names...Corrales/hatton... He's been in brawls and everything..

WHO does he HAVe to beat for you to Say he's an ATG?


he (floyd) can fight klitschko, and still be clowned...

Exact truth...

I can hear it now... Klitcscko was too slow for floyd.. of course he would win against a slow heavy weight...

But Ali and tyson would whoop him easily...

*Floyd beats tyson*

See tyson is a bum.. lennox beat him... so of course floyd would beat tyson...

But I'm sure rampage from the UFC would stomp floyd..

*Floyd beats Rampage*

That Big Sasquash from from the beef jerky commercials... I'm sure floyd wouldn't stand a chance against his jab...

*Floyd loses to sasquash*

See floyd sucks... always faced soft competition before Sasquash.

These threads are ridiculous, aside from the obvious floyd haters there are real boxing fans who dont think he fought the best possible competition at all times. I happen to be one of those people. But i was impressed with his victory over hatton and i think if he fought the 2 BEST fighters available in his next fights he would cement his legacy. to me the next 2 would be cotto and the winner of williams and whoever he fights in his second fight. if anyone still denied him after than they'd be crazy. but the rest of us have a legit claim and its ****** for you to not understand that.

[THE REED]

These threads are ridiculous, aside from the obvious floyd haters there are real boxing fans who dont think he fought the best possible competition at all times. I happen to be one of those people. But i was impressed with his victory over hatton and i think if he fought the 2 BEST fighters available in his next fights he would cement his legacy. to me the next 2 would be cotto and the winner of williams and whoever he fights in his second fight. if anyone still denied him after than they'd be crazy. but the rest of us have a legit claim and its ****** for you to not understand that.

im sorry i disagree.... cotto beat two name guys, pauls beaten one... floyd doesnt NEED to beat them... THEY NEED to beat floyd.... you dont beat one guy and then all the sudden your the pound for pound fighters biggest threat... no way... they need floyd... not the other way around...

floyd, is cottos biggest threat... not vice versa

floyd will fight again.. because he HAS too... and by that i mean... look at how much he brags... he LOVES the limelight.. he loves being called the best... and if you leave the sport... you lose that... he needs the attention.. he needs the rush.... thats why none of these fighters can successfully retire.... a month after oscar... he came out of retirement... all cotto has to do is keep runin his mouth.. he ll get the fight

[DA1CATAS]

im sorry i disagree.... cotto beat two name guys, pauls beaten one... floyd doesnt NEED to beat them... THEY NEED to beat floyd.... you dont beat one guy and then all the sudden your the pound for pound fighters biggest threat... no way... they need floyd... not the other way around...

floyd, is cottos biggest threat... not vice versa

floyd will fight again.. because he HAS too... and by that i mean... look at how much he brags... he LOVES the limelight.. he loves being called the best... and if you leave the sport... you lose that... he needs the attention.. he needs the rush.... thats why none of these fighters can successfully retire.... a month after oscar... he came out of retirement... all cotto has to do is keep runin his mouth.. he ll get the fight

Yea I'm sure he'll fight CaCa.. I'm just wondering will beating CaCa be enough...

I wouldn't mind seeing williams either... but He hasn't doen much yet.

[evanobando]

im sorry i disagree.... cotto beat two name guys, pauls beaten one... floyd doesnt NEED to beat them... THEY NEED to beat floyd.... you dont beat one guy and then all the sudden your the pound for pound fighters biggest threat... no way... they need floyd... not the other way around...

floyd, is cottos biggest threat... not vice versa

floyd will fight again.. because he HAS too... and by that i mean... look at how much he brags... he LOVES the limelight.. he loves being called the best... and if you leave the sport... you lose that... he needs the attention.. he needs the rush.... thats why none of these fighters can successfully retire.... a month after oscar... he came out of retirement... all cotto has to do is keep runin his mouth.. he ll get the fight

I guess you misunderstood the thread. obviously anyone needs mayweather more than he needs anyone. he just needs to beat them to cement his legacy and end any criticism. floyd is cottos biggest threat AND vice versa not one way or the other

[THE REED]

cotto gets outboxed all day

paul williams is floyds biggest threat truthfully

[SpeedKillz]

in order for some guys here to see him as an ATG, he would have to clear out every single division in boxing, then clear out ever division in the UFC, retire, come back at 45, and win a title or 2...

[DA1CATAS]

in order for some guys here to see him as an ATG, he would have to clear out every single division in boxing, then clear out ever division in the UFC, retire, come back at 45, and win a title or 2...

lmao

[DA1CATAS]

cotto gets outboxed all day

paul williams is floyds biggest threat truthfully

Hey don't say that.... Buy into the hype so it looks like cotto can beat him... then when CaCa loses we can say wow what a great fight..

I didnt think floyd could do it 40 times straight.

[Bahamut Zero]

in order for some guys here to see him as an ATG, he would have to clear out every single division in boxing, then clear out ever division in the UFC, retire, come back at 45, and win a title or 2...

Not only that, he's gotta beat Lance Armstrong in Tour De France, Michael Schumacher in F1, Tiger Woods in Golf, Michael Jordan in Basketball, Efren Reyes in Billiards, Ian Thorpe in swimming, maybe Royce Gracie in Jiujitsu, Garry Kasparov in chess...

...and Jackie Chan in Kung Fu.

[RisAri0]

he's already an ATG...he has nothing left to prove in my opinion...

but I will say this, I enjoy watching him in the ring...there's still competition @ 147...if anything he can make his legacy way much better by fighting cotto & williams who are both undefeated also...if he beats those 2 he's definitely top 3 of all time in my book...