Where does PBF belong in history now?

[squealpiggy]

He doesn't belong anywhere all time until he's retired and we've had a chance to reflect on it.

[Xcel]

Top 10 easily, maybe even top 5.

[sonofisis]

After the greatest performance of his career against what he called the toughest opponent he has ever faced where does PBF stand against the other all time greats if he was to retire and stay retired.

Not enough options! I'd have him in the top 20 and above the last option. I'll vote top 10 just to contribute, but it is not necessarily my position yet.

He doesn't belong anywhere all time until he's retired and we've had a chance to reflect on it.

Good point though..

[FISTIC ART]

..................

Last......... behind butter bean............

[-CANE-]

Last......... behind butter bean............

Butterbean was great and would have had too much speed for Ali and would have knocked him out cold in 3 rounds. Butterbean is definately top10 P4P all time.

[baya]

if floyd doesn't fight cotto, a proven and already established entity at 147 - then he is maybe top 20 p4p all time.

yes, great win but why stop there - at hatton? a known small guy from the 40's? take out cotto and cintron / margarito / or williams and then you're talking, with substance, as to why mayweather should be mentioned in the same breath of a robinson or armstrong.

with a bit more risk he could, otherwise he just could have.

[Burning Desire]

Top 10 easily, maybe even top 5.

Never top 5,

This list isn't in order

Sugar Ray Robinson
Willie Pep
Henry Armstrong
Roberto Duran
Harry Greb

I think your getting too carried away, Mayweather is nowhere even close to top 5.