Just Finished Watching Floyd Vs Castillo 1.Castillo Won..

[tills9191]

I thought he definitely won this.
PBF should be 37-1.

Oh well, can't do much about that now, but I know Floyd can be beaten as he has been already.

[THe TRiNiTY]

And so can Hatton. Everyone can. Not really that groundbreaking of a statement.

[TyrantT316]

Many great fighters of the past have had controversial decisions.

Many great fighters of the past have rematched and proven themselves despite that controversial decision.

Floyd Mayweather is on of those fighters who proved himself in the rematch despite the fan's disagreement with the JUDGES decision.

[THE REED]

thats funny, i just watched this fight last night too... i thought floyd was crushin it in the beginning, but castillo did win this fight hands down.. but in the rematch... he showed, he is on another level... if he didnt have the rematch it would be a bigger deal... but he did the rematch and whooped him so its moot now... but yes.. he can be beaten... and now im like oh man i know hatton can do better than castillo... but floyds hand was hurt in that fight... he couldnt throw like he wanted too... who knows

[Cuauhtémoc1520]

Castillo won I agree but in the rematch Mayweather showed me why he is the best pound4 pound fighter in the world.

I don't like Mayweather but he's pretty damn good.

[SkillspayBills]

Many great fighters of the past have had controversial decisions.

Many great fighters of the past have rematched and proven themselves despite that controversial decision.

Floyd Mayweather is on of those fighters who proved himself in the rematch despite the fan's disagreement with the JUDGES decision.

I concur to the fullest. I have no problem with people saying Castillo won but all doubt should have been quelled with the rematch.

[PRboxingfan]

Ah, but Mayweather doesn't have a bad shoulder for this fight (and didn't have one for the second Castillo fight and we saw how that one ended). Remember what he did to Jesus Chavez? Ricky's style is similar to Jesus' back then (jump in, try to bull you into the ropes/corner, etc) but Floyd totally bitched him.

Floyd will totally ***** Hatton. Those who think Hatton will win think so because of Hatton's style. Floyd has faced that style a few times before and beaten it EVERY time (Castillo twice, Chavez, Augustus, etc).

[MELLY-MEL...]

floyd came back in the 2nd fight and left no doubt that he won! u can also say that hatton lost to collazo in their fight, and ricky did not give a rematch! i give pbf props for rematching,and convincingly beating castillo the2nd time around. and i hate pbf as much as anyone, but gotta give credit where it is due!

[Burning Desire]

This thread gets brought up every other day, its really old and boring its been done to death. Mayweather had injury to his left shoulder and he wasn't 100 percent in the fight i had him losing by 1 point, but in the rematch he easily beat Castillo by atleast 3 rounds so who cares ??

[-Hyperion-]

seriously floyd fans does the fact that he won the second fight(a close and competitive fight btw) erase the fact that castillo shouldve won the first fight???, why is it so bad to lose??????especially against someone in the level of castillo???

srr lost is undefeated record to lamotta for gods sake...