Tito vs Floyd (in thier primes) at 147, who wins?

[AntonTheMeh]

Whitaker was way past it when he fought Tito. No way you count that loss against him, or use it as a measuring stick of any sort.

way past it is a stretch.
he was by many people's acounts robbed against oscar and,tested positive for coke his next fight,then fought tito about 2 years later.

[sonofisis]

The other thread about thier opposition sparked this fantasy fight in my mind. Who would win this 147 lbs matchup with both fighters in thier prime?

Floyd would outbox him like Oscar did.

[SpeedKillz]

floyd by SD

[Steak]

Whitaker actually did very well in that fight, if youve seen it. by no means at all did he win, but he was landing some pretty good punches, and he actually had Tito pretty hurt.

but yea, Whitaker was on crack at that point and time.

Its actually tough to call. Tito is much bigger than Floyd, and Floyd doesnt have this amazingly quick jab actually, at least at welterweight. but he does place it very well...
this is a tough one to call...For some reason I feel like Floyd would have a ton of trouble against Trinidad.

[2120]

tito by close dec

and add to the fact that at welter he hasnt really showcase his great boxing skill s like he did at 130 135 140
i think welter is just to big for him
if he would have fought a fighter of baldimir caliber at 130 135 140 he would have murder him

but at 147 he just to content to do enough to get easy dec win

granted tito has had problems with boxers but those boxers where about the same height as him

i think tito power and size would keep mayweather to defensive to be able to commit to offense

[ztrac79]

In my opinion he was on the decline when he fought Oscar. The fact that he did so well, even wining in some peoples mind just goes to show how much talent he had. When he fought Tito he showed little of the old sweet pea that I remember seeing.

[GTL]

Whitaker was way past it when he fought Tito. No way you count that loss against him, or use it as a measuring stick of any sort.

absolutely.. a prime pea would kill tito..
mayweather would eat him alive.. no offense, but its only the puerto ricans that say tito will win... tito lost to de la hoya.. he would not know what the **** do to against mayweather..
but your all entitled to you opinions.. tito would get dismantled till the end

[baya]

can't see tito beating floyd under any circumstances.

floyd UD - but God knows it wouldn't be easy.

[Addison]

Tito is my man but if he couldn't handle the slickness and cage-game of Wright and Hopkins he'd be in for a Diego Corrales caliber wipeout against Floyd Mayweather. It would be very similiar to that.

[AntonTheMeh]

absolutely.. a prime pea would kill tito..
mayweather would eat him alive.. no offense, but its only the puerto ricans that say tito will win... tito lost to de la hoya.. he would not know what the **** do to against mayweather..
but your all entitled to you opinions.. tito would get dismantled till the end

SERIOUSLY?KILL?