The Cotto fight only showed me that Mosley would walk through Floyd's punches.

[joepal]

And we all know that Shane punches harder than Floyd.

So the logical conclusion is Mosley by KO or UD. Agree?

[jabsRstiff]

And we all know that Shane punches harder than Floyd.

So the logical conclusion is Mosley by KO or UD. Agree?

Oscar DeLaHoya would handle Cotto's shots just as Mosley did. Over the years, Oscar has shown to be a bigger hitter at 147-154 than Shane is.
So, Oscar DeLaHoya, by your logic, would KO Floyd Mayweather.

If it wasn't for May 5th of this year, I'd say "excellent logic".

[joepal]

Oscar DeLaHoya would handle Cotto's shots just as Mosley did. Over the years, Oscar has shown to be a bigger hitter at 147-154 than Shane is.
So, Oscar DeLaHoya, by your logic, would KO Floyd Mayweather.

If it wasn't for May 5th of this year, I'd say "excellent logic".

It's excellent logic because, fekk you, Shane Mosley OWNS Oscar's ass. Or have you forgotten?

[Ray*]

Have alway maintain that Mosley would be the biggest threat to mayweather or maybe williams who i think in 2 years would beat any 147-154.

We all saw how the 36 yrs old made Cotto run and back off so i have no doubt that he would give mayweather hell but i would still edge towards Mayweather because mosley seem to have lost a lot of movement at this stage of his caree.

[Tuggers1986]

It's excellent logic because, fekk you, Shane Mosley OWNS Oscar's ass. Or have you forgotten?

Mosley would win 7 years ago. Now im not so sure.

[jabsRstiff]

It's excellent logic because, fekk you, Shane Mosley OWNS Oscar's ass. Or have you forgotten?

I prefer Mosley to Oscar. But, Oscar takes just as good a punch, while owning the heavier artillery.
Your thread is about how Shane would beat Floyd with his chin & firepower. You say nothing about Mosley's boxing skills, how he's better at coming forward than Oscar, or how his handspeed is superior. I'm just going off of your initial post, & I smashed it, lil' guy.

[realheavyhands]

they both take good punches but mosley doesnt care as much he likes to fight

[joepal]

they both take good punches but mosley doesnt care as much he likes to fight

Yep. If Floyd runs, expect Mosley to be in his element. And we all know that Floyd isn't going to fight toe-to-toe with Shane.

[eazy_mas]

Yep. If Floyd runs, expect Mosley to be in his element. And we all know that Floyd isn't going to fight toe-to-toe with Shane.

well you know it better he is going to win a boxing match as well as he is going to use the his shoulder to deflect Shanes shot and counter him.

counter punchs hurt more than normal punchs because you dont see it coming

[deevel79]

Floyd barely squeeked a SD over Oscar, and im sure anyone can agree with me that at this stage, Mosley will own Oscar even worst that he did back then.