Ring ratings seem kinda screwy

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Jim Jeffries
    rugged individualist
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Oct 2007
    • 20740
    • 1,376
    • 2,868
    • 54,838

    #1

    Ring ratings seem kinda screwy

    How does the Ring have Joel Casamayor above Juan Diaz at LW, and have Corey Spinks as their #1 JR MW and DLH as #3 (lost 3 of his last 5, 2 fights in 3 years), Zab Judah (1 win in his last 5) over Kermit Cintron (world champ), Hopkins as LHW champ (no world belt), Valuev above unbeaten world champ Ibragimov, etc, etc?
  • MoneyINC
    Banned
    Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
    • Aug 2006
    • 684
    • 36
    • 10
    • 801

    #2
    Becasue they want to

    Comment

    • Kball15
      HATTON WRIGHT PAVLIK
      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
      • Apr 2006
      • 15471
      • 491
      • 86
      • 22,680

      #3
      Originally posted by gavinz1970
      How does the Ring have Joel Casamayor above Juan Diaz at LW, and have Corey Spinks as their #1 JR MW and DLH as #3 (lost 3 of his last 5, 2 fights in 3 years), Zab Judah (1 win in his last 5) over Kermit Cintron (world champ), Hopkins as LHW champ (no world belt), Valuev above unbeaten world champ Ibragimov, etc, etc?
      well...

      A) Joel Casamayor was considered THE lightweight champ prior to the Cruz debacle, coming off a close win over the Late Corrales

      B) Cintron hasnt fought an elite fighter since Margarito, whom he lost to. Judah is coming off of 2 closely contested losses to fighters many people have in there top 5 p4p.

      C) Hopkins beat THE LHW champ in Antonio Tarver, and followed it up with a win over Winky Wright.

      D) Idk about the Valuev over Ibragimov, but Ibragimovs best win prior to Holyfield was Briggs... and his best win may still be Briggs cause Holyfield looked preeeeeeetty shot.

      Comment

      • EeZz
        Interim Champion
        Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
        • Nov 2006
        • 530
        • 42
        • 1
        • 6,671

        #4
        Ring's Ranking A.K.A Oscar's favorite boxers.

        Comment

        • MJ406
          Undisputed Champion
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Aug 2007
          • 4370
          • 61
          • 211
          • 12,288

          #5
          Casamayor is above because he's "The Ring's champion"

          and how is Luis Collazo STILL in the top 10 welterweights when all he did in 2007 was lose by UD to Shane Mosley? I know it makes zero sense .. but hey its the Bible of Boxing right?

          people really should start to take the Ring Magazine less seriously, not because it was brought by DLH, but because its ranking have bias ... yeah so do the sanctioning organizations, but a magazine also has bias as well

          Juan Diaz doesn't care about the Ring Title. why should we the fans?

          Comment

          • moy22487
            The silent poster
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Oct 2005
            • 3257
            • 99
            • 51
            • 9,856

            #6
            Originally posted by Kball15
            well...

            A) Joel Casamayor was considered THE lightweight champ prior to the Cruz debacle, coming off a close win over the Late Corrales

            B) Cintron hasnt fought an elite fighter since Margarito, whom he lost to. Judah is coming off of 2 closely contested losses to fighters many people have in there top 5 p4p.

            C) Hopkins beat THE LHW champ in Antonio Tarver, and followed it up with a win over Winky Wright.

            D) Idk about the Valuev over Ibragimov, but Ibragimovs best win prior to Holyfield was Briggs... and his best win may still be Briggs cause Holyfield looked preeeeeeetty shot.
            think you pritty much got it right

            Comment

            • Thread Stealer
              Undisputed Champion
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Sep 2007
              • 9657
              • 439
              • 102
              • 17,804

              #7
              Casamayor won the linear from Corrales in oct 2006.

              Casa hasn't retired, left the division, or officially lost a fight.

              you don't take away someone's belt because you disagree with the decision.

              joe louis didn't lose his crown after the first walcott fight. alfredo escalera didn't lose his wba belt after the everett fight. michael spinks didn't lose his ibf/ring belts because he got lucky against holmes the 2nd time around.

              Comment

              • Jim Jeffries
                rugged individualist
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Oct 2007
                • 20740
                • 1,376
                • 2,868
                • 54,838

                #8
                Originally posted by Thread Stealer
                Casamayor won the linear from Corrales in oct 2006.

                Casa hasn't retired, left the division, or officially lost a fight.

                you don't take away someone's belt because you disagree with the decision.

                joe louis didn't lose his crown after the first walcott fight. alfredo escalera didn't lose his wba belt after the everett fight. michael spinks didn't lose his ibf/ring belts because he got lucky against holmes the 2nd time around.
                Okay, then we should bring on Casamayor/Diaz already.

                Comment

                • Thread Stealer
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • Sep 2007
                  • 9657
                  • 439
                  • 102
                  • 17,804

                  #9
                  Originally posted by gavinz1970
                  Okay, then we should bring on Casamayor/Diaz already.
                  AGREED.

                  DIAZ WILL BEAT CASA UP.

                  I DON'T LIKE CASA.

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  TOP