is cotto the boxer of yer ??

[-Antonio-]

Probably not.

If Quintana was a month later, definitely yes. Makes debut in Welterweight division and goes 4-0 with three KO's over good competition.

[kenshin112]

calzaghe
cotto
mayweather
hatton
its a toss up between them come dec 9th we should know whose the fighter of the year

[Thread Stealer]

pavlik had a better year.

quintana was dec 06'

[-EX-]

Its either Cotto or Mayweather. I don't see how Calzaghe should be up there.
Floyd beat DLH-past his prime still very good
IF Floyd beats Hatton- prime fighter undefeated

Cotto beat Judah- prime above average fighter destroyed by Cotto
Cotto beat Mosley- past prime great fighter very skilled still very good

[kenshin112]

Its either Cotto or Mayweather. I don't see how Calzaghe should be up there.
Floyd beat DLH-past his prime still very good
IF Floyd beats Hatton- prime fighter undefeated

Cotto beat Judah- prime above average fighter destroyed by Cotto
Cotto beat Mosley- past prime great fighter very skilled still very good

how bout if Hatton beats mayweather?

[DA1CATAS]

Mayweather is Fighter of the YEAR... biggest fight of the year followed by Another huge fight... fought twice this year..

and also had the 2 biggest draws to boxing this year..


Of course its mayweather./... Still undefeated... still champion.