Bigger win : Cotto over Molsey or Floyd over Dela..

[C'MONMANG']

Which win was the bigger win. i aint talking about PPV #'s or revune..

[DA1CATAS]

Well you aint talkin PPV because we all know...


but I think people believed floyd could do it b4 he did it...


This is more of a surprise...he used a jab and boxed well in the start... and moved around decently.

SO I'D HAVE TO SAY COTTO'S WIN IS BIGGER.

[AntonTheMeh]

c'mongmang'

[Fox McCloud]

Probably Mayweather's... merely because it was in a weight class higher for the winner.

Both were close decisions, against previous legends who had faded a bit, but not by a whole lot.

The fact that Mayweather had to go to 154 instead of 147 to do is the tiebreaker.

[RodBarker]

Cotto is a very big welter , Floyd gave Oscar 14 pnds , makes a big difference , Oscar and Mosley are at about the same stage of faded but are still very dangerous and only the elite will beat them .

[Mozza]

I reckon about the same but they are both impressive.

[ßringer]

Probably Mayweather's... merely because it was in a weight class higher for the winner.

Both were close decisions, against previous legends who had faded a bit, but not by a whole lot.

The fact that Mayweather had to go to 154 instead of 147 to do is the tiebreaker.

Highly respect you but have to disagree.

Mayweather was the clear favorite to beat Oscar despite moving up in weight, 9 out of 10 analysts had pegged Mayweather to win, as did the general public. 9 out of 10 analysts and the general public picked Mosley to win, and win easily by bold predictions like "early TKO" or "late KO". I don't know of many other people here aside from myself who bet on Cotto, or even gave him a fighting chance for that matter.

[C'MONMANG']

Cotto is a very big welter , Floyd gave Oscar 14 pnds , makes a big difference , Oscar and Mosley are at about the same stage of faded but are still very dangerous and only the elite will beat them .

14 pounds? lol