If Juan Diaz

[Slotff]

beats Casamayor, Campbell, Katsidis, Diaz and Pacquiao, is he an ATG lightweight in your eyes? I know its alot to ask, to beat all those great fighters, but I just wanna hear what people say.

Lightweight has had greats like Benny Leonard and Duran over the years, so its alot to say that he would rank among them, but if he beats those five, I would say top 10 of all time. He would have beaten everyone of significance in his era.

[EeZz]

the key word here is "IF" and thats a big IF.

[Slotff]

the key word here is "IF" and thats a big IF.

Oh of course, but IF he does. State your mind

[moy22487]

beats Casamayor, Campbell, Katsidis, Diaz and Pacquiao, is he an ATG lightweight in your eyes? I know its alot to ask, to beat all those great fighters, but I just wanna hear what people say.

Lightweight has had greats like Benny Leonard and Duran over the years, so its alot to say that he would rank among them, but if he beats those five, I would say top 10 of all time. He would have beaten everyone of significance in his era.

campbell katsidis and im assuming david diaz, they are good but they are not big names. none of them are hall of famers. pacman is to small and hasnt faught in that division. casamayor is getting old.
its will get him in the talks of top fighters, but he needs more. he will do good if he keeps putting on big fights

[ElGranLuchador]

Oh of course, but IF he does. State your mind

definetly only beating pac will make him a mexican legend

[EeZz]

Oh of course, but IF he does. State your mind

Without a doubt! He beat all the fighters that he need to fight.

[moy22487]

definetly only beating pac will make him a mexican legend

the word legend being used to losely in your post

[Mike Tyson77]

definetly only beating pac will make him a mexican legend

Mexico would be partying for a week if he KO'd Pac. That's if

[BROOKLYN CESAR]

Yeah i think he could up there atleast!!!