Who Can Joe Calzaghe Beat Without Being Criticised

[Left2body]

Its not that people criticize him. I give Calz huge props and now view him as a great fighter. The criticism comes from Calz fan boys who are now saying that he is a GOAT.

There hyperbole concerning Calz has caused many to add some reason to the threads such rediculous threads as "#1 p4p" and "JC would've KO'd prime RJ and beaten prime JT".

Lets all enjoy the win and excellent performance and leave it at that.

[Jim Jeffries]

Mayweather is hated on because he thinks hes the best fighter that ever laced a pair of gloves yet he has only beaten 1 Elite fighter Dela Hoya

And De La Hoya had had only 1 fight in 3 years and had lost 2 of his last 4.

[Jim Jeffries]

Its not that people criticize him. I give Calz huge props and now view him as a great fighter. The criticism comes from Calz fan boys who are now saying that he is a GOAT.

There hyperbole concerning Calz has caused many to add some reason to the threads such rediculous threads as "#1 p4p" and "JC would've KO'd prime RJ and beaten prime JT".

Lets all enjoy the win and excellent performance and leave it at that.

Well he definitely belongs in the discussion of GOAT super middleweights.

[.Mik.]

I dont think that anyone is saying that Calzaghe would KO anyone who is also elite. He may stop a few people still, but his knock out power is certainly missing at this weight. Maybe when he moves up he'll find it again...

[Vladimir303]

Mayweather is hated on because he thinks hes the best fighter that ever laced a pair of gloves yet he has only beaten 1 Elite fighter Dela Hoya

He has beaten plenty more then 1........believe that.

Calzaghe has only beaten 2........believe that as well.

[Dynamite Kid]

Its not that people criticize him. I give Calz huge props and now view him as a great fighter. The criticism comes from Calz fan boys who are now saying that he is a GOAT.

There hyperbole concerning Calz has caused many to add some reason to the threads such rediculous threads as "#1 p4p" and "JC would've KO'd prime RJ and beaten prime JT".

Lets all enjoy the win and excellent performance and leave it at that.

oh yeah and Pacman & Mayweather & RJJ fans dont do that ,its only asv outrageous as the people who claim RJJ is the best p4p fighter of all time yet the guy only fought Hopkins & Toney


Calzaghe would have beaten JT

[El Jesus]

oh yeah and Pacman & Mayweather & RJJ fans dont do that ,its only asv outrageous as the people who claim RJJ is the best p4p fighter of all time yet the guy only fought Hopkins & Toney


Calzaghe would have beaten JT

why do you think he would have beaten toney, at 168, have you ever seen toney at that weight? seriously

[Dynamite Kid]

He has beaten plenty more then 1........believe that.

Calzaghe has only beaten 2........believe that as well.

has he **** ,if u think Castillo & Corrales are Elite fighters let me tell u something they are no where near as good as other great lighweights like Mosley ,J C Chavez as for Gatti ,Baldomir , do me a favour Nuthugger

[Dynamite Kid]

why do you think he would have beaten toney, at 168, have you ever seen toney at that weight? seriously

i never said Calzaghe would beat Toney at SMW

[EliteSoldier]

Floyd Mayweathers coming up to 175 to fight Calzaghe... hahaha!!! Lets so who the best is then