Do you agree with this P4P List?

[NAPO]

i really don't think winky wright and rafael marquez belong on the p4p rankings calderon should definitely should be there pavlik deserved because on how he went his way up so it should be like this.

1-floyd maywheather
2-manny pacquiao
3-joe calzaghe
4-benard popkins
5-juan manuel marquez
6-israel vazquez
7-ricky hatton
8-Ivan calderon
9-miguel cotto
10-kelly pavlik

[Horus]

Not a good list, IMO. Bernard Hopkins and Winky Wright should not be in there. (Both faded even tho still formidable) We also disagree as to order, but that's not as important as identifying the top ten.

IMO p4p is about the sum of a boxer's skills when he is at his best. I don't like having over the hill fighters in the p4p list. Hopkins and Wright are beyond prime now. Wright is still close to p4p because his skills have always been almost totally defensive and have not dropped off too much. However, Hopkins is not even close to what he used to be from an offensive standpoint. He doesn't even belong in the top 15 p4p, IMO.

This was my list from 5 days ago. I'm sticking with it:

10-28-2007, 07:41 PM
Wiley Hyena
Undisputed Champion



Join Date: Sep 2007
Rating:
Posts: 2,171
Points: 46,552.25
Bank: 0.00
Total Points: 46,552.25
Donate

vCash: 500



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Pacquiao
2. Calzaghe
3. Hatton
4. Mayweather
5. Israel Vasquez
6. Pavlik
7. J. M. Marquez
8. Cotto
9. Mosely
10. Kessler

Edit: I'm willing to move Calderon in for Kessler after last night, but Kessler is still a big contender for p4p.

remember this