Cotto in the "not so safe" category according to Ericl Rasin...

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • TintaBoricua
    Waiting on MvC4...
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Oct 2007
    • 3455
    • 509
    • 176
    • 9,466

    #1

    Cotto in the "not so safe" category according to Ericl Rasin...

    An article in ESPNBoxing (or actually MAXBoxing):

    How many perfect records will fall this fall?

    Naturally, I'm bummed that Adrian Diaconu and Oleg Maskaev have joined boxing's seemingly endless list of walking wounded. But I'm not going to allow it to obscure the fact that the fight schedule from now until early December is still as good a seasonal stretch as I've seen in my 10 years of boxing writing. Part of what makes it so exceptional is just how many undefeated fighters are putting their zeroes on the line this autumn. Almost all of the big fights feature an unbeaten contestant, and three of the very biggest battles feature two perfect records in a "someone's 'O' has got to go" scenario: Jermain Taylor vs. Kelly Pavlik, Joe Calzaghe vs. Mikkel Kessler, and Floyd Mayweather vs. Ricky Hatton.


    In all, I counted 20 fighters between now and Dec. 8 who are putting their undefeated records on the line in significant fights. And by "significant," I don't mean 3-0 or 5-0 or even 10-0 prospects on club show undercards; I'm talking champions, titlists, or at least extremely high profile prospects. So I took the 20 heroes with zeroes and broke them down into three categories: The extremely safe (I'd be shocked if they lost), The kind of safe (I don't expect them to lose, but I could see it happening), and the not-at-all-safe (they're somewhere in the 50/50 range or worse). And here's some reassuring news: I put 10 of the 20 in the last category, which means we have some competitive fights on our hands, fights in which "O's" may very well go.

    The extremely safe

    Chad Dawson Once upon a time, Epifanio Mendoza was a highly dangerous puncher responsible for derailing Tokunbo Olajide and Rubin Williams. But his limitations have been exposed, and remember, his best work was done at middleweight. At light heavyweight, he's no match for Dawson. Since he's a replacement opponent for a replacement opponent, it's unfair to complain too much, but this is a mismatch nevertheless.

    Amir Khan. I don't know much about Scott Lawton, the British opponent Olympic silver medalist Khan is scheduled to face on Oct. 6. But I do know he has four knockout wins in 24 fights, and I know he has a draw against a 1-8 fighter on his record. I also know Khan's people aren't looking to take any risks with him right now. This hardly even counts as a "significant" fight, except Khan just might be the best under-drinking-age fighter on the planet.

    Sergio Mora. As we learned a couple of days ago, the opponent for "The Latin Snake" on Oct. 16 is going to be Elvin Ayala, a twice-beaten ex-prospect whom I saw fight live a couple of times very early in his career. He didn't impress me much then, and two decision losses to David Banks in the past year don't impress me either. I'm a believer in Mora, and as long as he doesn't suffer a huge mental letdown because he's in there with someone other than Kassim Ouma, this should be an easy night's work.

    Steve Molitor. At first glance, an opponent with a 58-8-1 (35) record sounds like a tough dude who's been around the block and can't be taken for granted. But in 67 fights, Fahsan 3K Battery has never beaten a half-decent contender. In his current 14-fight winning streak, 10 of his 14 opponents had losing records. When he's stepped up, he's always lost (most notably against the ordinary Art Simonyan and by fourth-round knockout against Manny Pacquiao). The semi-unproven Molitor may or may not be the greatest thing Canada has produced since William Shatner, but I can't imagine him struggling much with this unworthy Thai challenger.

    Floyd Mayweather. Some people aren't going to agree with this opinion, but Mayweather-Hatton strikes me as a "superfight" with two possible outcomes: Mayweather wins comfortably, and Mayweather wins ridiculously comfortably. Hatton's smothering style would pose problems to Mayweather if the Brit was bigger and a heavier puncher. But he is what he is, and I don't think he has the tools to damage Floyd. Frankly, I expect him to get boxed silly. As with Mayweather-De La Hoya, I figure the 24/7 documentaries to be a lot more memorable than the fight.

    The kind-of safe

    Andre Berto. I was tempted to put the '04 Olympian in the "extremely safe" category, but I can't get the image of that Cosme Rivera uppercut dropping him out of my head, and opponent David Estrada is no joke -- he's a gatekeeper who only loses to top fighters. He's already bumped off two unbeaten prospects (Nurhan Suleymanoglu and Chris Smith). I'm pretty sure Berto is better than those guys. But this is no Nito Bravo or Miguel Figueroa he's up against.

    Sultan Ibragimov. Logic says a legitimate top heavyweight shouldn't have anything to fear against a 44-year-old Evander Holyfield. But logic has said a lot of things about Holyfield that turned out to be incorrect. I definitely view Ibragimov as the favorite, but I can't count "The Real Deal" out -- especially because the Russian reeks of mediocrity. Plus, according to Rocky IV, the aging American legend can beat the Russian on his home turf. And if we can't trust the movie-making of Sly Stallone, what can we trust?

    Lucian Bute. The Romanian-Canadian super middleweight seems to have almost every edge in his alphabet title challenge against Alejandro Berrio in Montreal, especially with all four of Berrio's losses coming by knockout, but the Colombian with 25 stoppages in 26 wins definitely has the ol' puncher's chance. No matter how high class Bute may turn out to be, you're never totally safe against a guy who can bomb like Berrio can. Bute just needs to keep his hands up and keep his forehead out of kissing range.

    Alexander Povetkin. Though he has yet to fully prove it in the ring, I'm of the belief that the 28-year-old Povetkin, a veteran of only 13 pro fights, is already one of the five best heavyweights in the world. Consider: Larry Donald, who in his previous fight lost a controversial majority decision to Nicolay Valuev, didn't win a single round against Povetkin. Donald also recently drew with Ray Austin, who also drew with Sultan Ibragimov. What I'm trying to say here is that as capable as Chris Byrd still is at 37, I make the 2004 Olympic gold medalist a solid favorite in their Oct. 27 bout.

    Andre Ward. On Nov. 16 on "ShoBox", America's lone '04 gold medalist takes on Roger Cantrell, who's compiled a 12-0 (8) record while taking on the most mediocre middleweights, super middleweights and light heavyweights that the Tacoma, Washington, area has to offer. Naturally, Ward is the favorite. But Cantrell's nickname is "Never Can Tell" (a horrible nickname, but potentially appropriate for this fight), and quite a few good prospects have gotten upended on "ShoBox" over the years. Having never seen Cantrell fight, I can't pick Ward to join the list. But I also can't say my jaw would hit the floor if he did.
  • TintaBoricua
    Waiting on MvC4...
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Oct 2007
    • 3455
    • 509
    • 176
    • 9,466

    #2
    The not-at-all safe

    Kelly Pavlik. Last week, I went on record picking Pavlik to beat Jermain Taylor for the middleweight title. I'm certainly not so overconfident as to call him a "safe" choice though. Taylor is athletic, he has arguably the best trainer in the world, and if he can put all the pieces together for once, Pavlik could be in trouble.

    Jermain Taylor. Having said that, I still view Taylor as the underdog. And against a guy who punches like Pavlik, nobody is safe.

    Daiki Kameda. Maybe you've never heard of Kameda. But in Japan, he and his brother Koki are like the Venus and Serena of boxing. So his challenge of Daisuke Naito -- at the tender age of 18 and in just his 11th pro fight -- is a huge deal. And he's clearly the underdog against the fighter who just ended the six-year reign of Pongsaklek Wonjongkam.

    Juan Diaz. I lean toward "The Baby Bull" to get the better of Julio Diaz on Oct. 13, but it sure isn't safe match-making. This is simply a great fight where neither guy is more than about a 7-5 favorite. Julio is the longer and more versatile of the two, but Juan is younger, more energetic, and as Teddy Atlas would say, he hasn't learned how to lose. He's definitely in danger of learning against his fellow Diaz, however.

    Eddie Chambers. The Philadelphia sports fan in me would love to say that this unbeaten Philly heavyweight is going to the top, but being a Philadelphia sports fan also means expecting disappointment. I've watched the Lindros and Iverson eras pass without a championship, and the McNabb era is certainly heading that way; if the Phillies can't build a championship team around the incredible Howard-Utley-Rollins trio, you'll soon be able to find me in a strait jacket, ****ing my head against the wall of my rubber room. Anyway, I'm not completely sold on "Fast Eddie," and I make him a slight 'dog against Calvin Brock. All things being equal, unless Bernard Hopkins is involved, bet against Philly.

    Joe Calzaghe. If you know anything about boxing, you know that Calzaghe-Mikkel Kessler is one of the best matchups in years, and you know only a biased and blind Calzaghe fan or Kessler fan could view either man as a heavy favorite. They're both putting their undefeated records in extreme danger with this fight. Good for both of them. And better for us.

    Mikkel Kessler. See above.

    Miguel Cotto. I could probably write "see above" again, since Cotto vs. Shane Mosley has all the same appeal as Calzaghe-Kessler, except only one of the participants is undefeated. Every time I even begin to think about picking a winner in this fight, I give myself a headache trying to figure it out.

    Joan Guzman. The Dominican's bout with Humberto Soto is the great underhyped fight on the fall calendar, the gem obscured by all of the higher-profile showdowns. They may not be PPV-worthy names, but Guzman-Soto is every bit as intriguing and unpredictable a pairing as Cotto-Mosley and Calzaghe-Kessler.

    Ricky Hatton. You can debate whether Mayweather belongs in the first category; you can't dispute the fact that his December 8 opponent belongs in this one. I'm almost certain Hatton's "O" will go. But even if you give him a better shot than I do, there's no such thing as a safe fight against the most gifted boxer in the world. The streak of great fights from now through December will end with someone losing his perfect record. And I can save you the suspense: That someone will be Hatton.
    Comments? I'm not debating anything, just contributing news to the site incase any posters are missing it.

    Comment

    • AntonTheMeh
      STOP CRYIN
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Sep 2007
      • 21222
      • 700
      • 709
      • 31,623

      #3
      well that's what it's supposed to be this list means ****.everybody knows how skill full shane is.

      Comment

      Working...
      TOP