A new Pound-for-Pound List....and it's very good!!

[Vladimir303]

exactl roy had power to duck threats and fight his hand picked bums until he met a real a class fighter and lost. shame cya later fat ****er

All Calzaghe had to do is come to America like Ricky Hatton did and he would have gotten his shot at a P4P king in Roy.

Would Floyd have fought Hatton in Manchaster right now? I don't think AND Hatton knew that and understood that he needed to come to America to fight the top guys.

And now he is getting ready to fight the current P4P King Floyd.....something Joe couldn't do back then because he was too chicken **** to come to American AND STILL IS.

This conversation is done.

[WLAD OWNS]

That p4p list is pure bull****, there is no true p4p list.

[Unseen]

All Calzaghe had to do is come to America like Ricky Hatton did and he would have gotten his shot at a P4P king in Roy.

Would Floyd have fought Hatton in Manchaster right now? I don't think AND Hatton knew that and understood that he needed to come to America to fight the top guys.

And now he is getting ready to fight the current P4P King Floyd.....something Joe couldn't do back then because he was too chicken **** to come to American AND STILL IS.

This conversation is done.

ye and hatton left warren which calzaghe wont do considering warren ahs looked after him. all roy has to do is decide not to fight a bum and fight a champion like joe. it was found out when he fought quailty opposition fool.

[joepal]

I only had to check the first spot to see if this guy was legit. I was not disappointed.

Very good analysis btw.

[-Antonio-]

How can Paul Williams be on the cusp after beating only Margarito? Ivan Calderon deserves more respect than that.

[Jim Jeffries]

I only had to check the first spot to see if this guy was legit. I was not disappointed.

Very good analysis btw.

He has Pac at #1, so the list must be perfect, ROFL.

[revs1227]

I agree this list is ****

List makes no sense and I'll tell you why.

Pacquiao should NOT be above Mayweather.

Hopkins is WAY too high for someone fighting ONCE per year.

Wright at 6???? He should be lower tier.

Calzaghe at 10? A guy undefeated for over a decade is WAY TOO LOW, especially under guys like Pavlik, Vazquez and Marquez.

Juan Manuel TOO HIGH.

lol at the floyd girls mad a pac

[Parody]

Somehow you ALWAYS speak before researching ANY FACTS.

A. Trinidad is BLOWN UP middleweight that Calzaghe, Kessler of any other fighter at 168 would murder.

B. A Calzaghe-Johnson fight was made four times and cancelled four times because of injuires on BOTH ends.

C. Tarver lost to Hopkins before the fight could ever happen. There were talks and Tarver asked for almost 10 million.

D. When was James Toney or Kelly Pavlik available for Calzaghe? Where do you get this **** from?

E. Jones priced himself out last year and Calzaghe has been at 168 while Jones has been at 175. Taylor priced himself out this year and took Pavlik instead.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EMLgVtZgtU0

[baya]

having ricky hatton above joe calz is INEXCUSABLE, having him above winky wright is just simple short-yellow-bus ******ity.

this list is as bad as the others.

[sonofisis]

Why are we bickering over a random, unofficial list? The most relied above for all boxing outlets has PBF at #1 and rightly so. Pac has been KOed early in his career by bums and has since only beaten over-the-hill fighters. The one and only reason he's at #2 is excitement because most people in the top 10 totally **** on him skills wise.