what if: Hatton vs. Juan Diaz @ 140?

[joepal]

In case you haven't read my earlier posts on the subject (please feel free to look them up from recently), I have always said that the fight could've gone either way. Fights are won by winning rounds. I find it hard to believe that both Floyd and Castillo didn't win 5 rounds each. The other 2 rounds determined who won the fight. IMO, it could've gone 7-5, 6-6, or 5-7 on any given scorecard. Unlike yourself, I can judge a fight based on the scoring criteria, not based on who I would like to win. Castillo was not "robbed" in that fight. A close decision didn't go his way and anyone who doesn't see that has no credibility.

And I say that JLC won that fight clearly. Who's the nuthugger now, *****?

[ThaHorseman]

And I say that JLC won that fight clearly. Who's the nuthugger now, *****?

I think that just makes you an idiot. Not just for thinking that JLC "CLEARLY" won, but also for trying to an internet ganster.

[joepal]

I think that just makes you an idiot. Not just for thinking that JLC "CLEARLY" won, but also for trying to an internet ganster.

So you think me saying that JLC clearly won makes me an idiot? Gotcha there *****.

That's exactly what a Floyd nuthugger would say about the first Castillo fight.

[Hatton43-0-0]

I recon Hatton would beat him!!