Poll: Floyd v. Castillo I...who won?

[Wiley Hyena]

That's the opposite of what happened? I seem to recall Mayweather winning both fights according to judges scores. Maybe I'm crazy.

I think we're talking about what really happened.

[Wiley Hyena]

Yeah. If Dirt E Gomez had great morals, then Mother Teresa is a slut.

....lol.........

[Dirt E Gomez]

Yeah. If Dirt E Gomez had great morals, then Mother Teresa is a slut.

You can tell how moral of a person I am by how I judge fights? You have a spectacular ability if that's the case.

As for what "really" happened: It's fair to assert that more people would claim Mayweather won both fights before claiming Castillo won both.

[joepal]

You can tell how moral of a person I am by how I judge fights? You have a spectacular ability if that's the case.

As for what "really" happened: It's fair to assert that more people would claim Mayweather won both fights before claiming Castillo won both.

Dirt E, why doncha just off yourself and be done with it?

[Wiley Hyena]

You can tell how moral of a person I am by how I judge fights? You have a spectacular ability if that's the case.

As for what "really" happened: It's fair to assert that more people would claim Mayweather won both fights before claiming Castillo won both.

Wrong. Most people would claim that Castillo won the first fight, and almost won the second fight.

[robjr]

castillo won.

[Vladimir303]

There have been many recent posts regarding the first fight between Jose Luis Castillo and Floyd Mayweather, Jr.

I thought the decision for Floyd was nothing less than highway robbery. And incredibly, the judges had Floyd winning by a wide margin. Meanwhile, Lederman and Merchant had Castillo up by 4 points if I recall correctly. If any recent decision in boxing should have prompted a criminal investigation, this one is it, IMO.

What do you think?

LMAO at criminal investigation. How desperate can one be to see a fighter lose to call the Castillo win a big robbery. Whatever disagreements there are about this fight every fair and balanced person should agree that this was a close fight.

I had it 114-112 for Floyd. That's 6 rounds to 5 with 1 even. That is a close fight. I'm a Mayweather fan and If I really wanted to I could have scored it biased and made it look like Floyd won more then just 6 rounds but I didn't

It's pathetic how every Floyd hater gets on somebody when they had the fight scored for Floyd like Castillo was dominating the fight when he really didn't.

[Ray Ray]

It was a robbery because it wasnt even close. Castillo owned that black ass in the first fight.

I also think he won in the rematch IMO.

Joepal you're a sorry sack of ****. Why do you have to go racial???

[Tony628]

castillo definately won and anyone who argues he didn't is a nuthugger.

[Wiley Hyena]

castillo definately won and anyone who argues he didn't is a nuthugger.

......agreed...............