NEW (and controversial) POUND-FOR-POUND LIST

[SkillspayBills]

this is one of the most accurate p4p lists i have seen in a long time. its good to see a respected writer giving credit to the mexican bad ass antonio margarito and bringing the facts that mayweather ducked him for $8 million. mayweather is only #1 on the coward for coward lists.

lmao, Man you make my day you really do.

[SkillspayBills]

IMO its a bad list, not for the Floyd and Margarito listing, but for the Bernard Hopkins listing. He hasn't been at his prime in years. Israel Vasquez should be on there as well.

Are you going to sit there and legitemetly tell me Floyd Mayweather is a not a top 2 p4p fighter. Even worse are you going to tell me Margarito IS a top 10 p4p fighter?!?

[Wiley Hyena]

Are you saying Mayweather should be out of the top two or three, and that Margarito should be on the list?

No. I'm saying that Bernard Hopkins should NOT be on there. Who gives a crap about the order? That's all subjective bull**** anyway. But, you can reasonably narrow it down to ten. And Hopkins should not be there. I've also got my doubts about Shane. Israel Vasquez should be in there, too. IMO

[Easy-E]

Terrible, terrible list.

[WHB3]

Controversial should be replaced by idiotic and deliberately provocative.

Amen brother. Margarito in the top 10??!?! LOL. That's absurd.

[AntonTheMeh]

calderon,pavlik,and dawson should be in that ****.dude talks about floyd making the list because of what he did,at 130,hopkins is on that list for beating tito and the same for winky.

[Dirt E Gomez]

this is one of the most accurate p4p lists i have seen in a long time. its good to see a respected writer giving credit to the mexican bad ass antonio margarito and bringing the facts that mayweather ducked him for $8 million. mayweather is only #1 on the coward for coward lists.

I AGREE!!! BEST p4p LIST EVER!!!!!!!!!1111eleven

[-Antonio-]

My mouth dropped when I saw Winky above Floyd. The rest is just laughable.

[THe TRiNiTY]

why should rafael marquez be on the p4p or israel??? because they had 2 great fights between each other??? they haven't really fought nobody but themselves isral vazquez should at maximum be on 7 or 8.Ivan Calderon has acomplished more and he is not in alot of ppls P4P.

but this p4p is horrible margarito on the list???

No one said they should be HIGH on the list, though they should. Fact is, they had great SKILLFUL fights. On top of that, Both have fought great opponents for their weight divisions. Considering who they really have to choose from. I'm a huge fan of Ivan Calderon.. but can you gimme two or three BIG name fighters he has on his resume?

[THe TRiNiTY]

No. I'm saying that Bernard Hopkins should NOT be on there. Who gives a crap about the order? That's all subjective bull**** anyway. But, you can reasonably narrow it down to ten. And Hopkins should not be there. I've also got my doubts about Shane. Israel Vasquez should be in there, too. IMO

Hopkins was competetive with his two recent losses, and came back to beat Tarver and Wright, both pretty convincingly, too. Especially in the Tarver fight, jumping up two weight divisions to do such a thing. He was number one on most people's list before his losses, and because they were close, he didn't drop off the list, then he has come back with two quality wins. What's not to acknowledge, here?