Corrales & Castillo A Class Or B Class

[Dynamite Kid]

keep in mind that niether of them have notable wins over any A Class fighter

IMO they are B Class fighters ,

my definition of an A Class fighter is someone who beats other A Class fightrs

Dela Hoya ,Mosley ,Winky,hopkins ,Barrera,Pacquiao

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

keep in mind that niether of them have notable wins over any A Class fighter

IMO they are B Class fighters ,

my definition of an A Class fighter is someone who beats other A Class fightrs

Dela Hoya ,Mosley ,Winky,hopkins ,Barrera,Pacquiao

You said that Miguel Cotto was an "A" class fighter. What A class guys did he beat? What A class guys did Oscar beat?

Thanks in advance.

[msagrain]

castiollo was an A in his prime but he no longer is.

[Dynamite Kid]

You said that Miguel Cotto was an "A" class fighter. What A class guys did he beat? What A class guys did Oscar beat?

Thanks in advance.

Dela Hoya beat Whittaker ,he is a multiple weight World Champion ,lets just see what the results are eh,you maybe right about Cotto but he is clearly an A Class fighter in most peoples eyes and certainly better than Castillo & Corrales ,Gatti,Baldomir ,Judah

[SkillspayBills]

Dela Hoya beat Whittaker ,he is a multiple weight World Champion ,lets just see what the results are eh,you maybe right about Cotto but he is clearly an A Class fighter in most peoples eyes and certainly better than Castillo & Corrales ,Gatti,Baldomir ,Judah

You are contradicting yourself. You say Cas and Corrales aren't A-class fighters because they haven't beaten any but when asked which A-class fighter Cotto has beaten you don't name anyone.

[Dynamite Kid]

Dela Hoya beat Whittaker ,he is a multiple weight World Champion ,lets just see what the results are eh,you maybe right about Cotto but he is clearly an A Class fighter in most peoples eyes and certainly better than Castillo & Corrales ,Gatti,Baldomir ,Judah

A Class :great

B Class : good

C Class :average

[Chups]

They would have to be a B.

[Dynamite Kid]

You are contradicting yourself. You say Cas and Corrales aren't A-class fighters because they haven't beaten any but when asked which A-class fighter Cotto has beaten you don't name anyone.

do you think Cotto is a B Class fighter ,well we dont need to debate it do we he still better than Corrles ,Castillo ,Gatti ,Baldomir ,do you agree

well there you go i dont need stats to prove he is A Class the majority of the fans will testify to it, illl make a thread of that if you like if you need convincing

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Dela Hoya beat Whittaker ,he is a multiple weight World Champion ,lets just see what the results are eh,you maybe right about Cotto but he is clearly an A Class fighter in most peoples eyes and certainly better than Castillo & Corrales ,Gatti,Baldomir ,Judah

Nah, man... you said that to be an "A" you have to beat an "A".

The version of Pernell that Oscar beat was far from his best days. Pernell Whitaker is one of my favourite and one of the best fighters ever. But he had lost a couple of steps by the time he got to Oscar. If you saw the fight BEFORE Oscar, you would see Pea eat canvas a 2 or 3 times before getting a VERY GOOD stoppage win.

Question: If Castillo and Corrales are B-level, then what are Collazo and Urango? Just for benchmarking purposes.

[Slotff]

Castillo dosn't have wins over any A-Class fighters you say?

What about:

Joel Casamayor (Current lightweight World Champion), Juan Lazcano (A fighter who knocked out Stevie Johnston), Stevie Johnston himself X2 (Champion at the time), Jorge Paez, Julio Diaz (Two time lightweight world champion with a KO win over Jesus Chavez), or Diego Corrales himself who had beaten Casamayor, beaten Freitas, and beaten Manfredy. If all those names are not enough for you then what about a win over the reigning Pound for Pound king of the world Floyd Mayweather Jr?

If Casamayor, Lazcano, Johnston, Diaz, Corrales, Paz and Mayweather are not good names to have on your resume, than what are?