Malignaggi: Untested or Underrated?

[steptwome]

true out of cotto's 10 championship fights he was actually the only one who lasted 12 rounds.

Don't forget Lovemore N'dou went the full 12 rounds with Cotto

[-Antonio-]

Underrated. He'll prove how good he is in the next few years.

[feed-the-goat]

Best at 140. Pretty good boxer.

both junior witter and ricky hatton would take him to the cleaners so how can he be the best at 140?

[Azteca]

Untested. He tested himself against a world class caliber fighter and he was blown out of the water. Showed great heart - which was suprising but not world class skills. His awkward style only works against B rate pressure fighters. Hatton would have him for lunch. Same with Witter. I think even Harris would outbox him...it's a styles matchup.

[merjohn32]

To answer the thread title:

He was tested by Cotto and he failed.

He might be ready to take the test again. Will he pass or fail?
We'll see...

[revs1227]

hes def tested
took a nice beating from cotto..
i think hes a good boxer he has very quick hands and can move nicely hell be aroudn 4 a while ..
i think he took that cotto fight 2 early and didnt no what he was in 4 lol

[Easy-E]

He is tested. He failed the test.

21 fights deep facing a hyped world champion who has destroyed nearly all of his opponents and not only going the full 12 with Cotto but also making the fight competitive and exciting shows he didnt fail anything.
It was a great, gutty preformance by Paulie.

[-Antonio-]

Malignaggi did well enough to lose 116-111 on my card. He gets points for making it a good competitive fight against a borderline elite.

[Sttuddahboy619]

He's a good boxer but failed a difficult exam!

[juancho]

i think Paulie is good ,that Ndou fight was an exciting fight for involving a pure boxer like him