If Mayweather loses...

[BmoreBrawler]

If hatton beats mayweather, then hatton gets in the hof if mayweather gets in the hof.

[moofo]

No, and Floyd would in the HOF. Floyd has 5 titles in 5 weightclasses in 10-11years. If Ricky beat Floyd, and then beat Cotto or Mosley and then maybe Malignaggi then he'd for sure be a HOF. Or if he moved up and won titles. Ricky still has a lot of time, but he won't beat Mayweather.

Shame he didn't beat the best to get 3 of those titles.
I wonder if the HOF will point that out?

[Fox McCloud]

Shame he didn't beat the best to get 3 of those titles.
I wonder if the HOF will point that out?

I'm actually having a hard time guessing which divisions you think he beat the best in. Let's start with the obvious:

He beat the best at 135 in Castillo for the title. Period.

He beat the worst at 140 to get his title. Period.

Now for the in-betweeners.

I would venture that you think he beat the best at 130...

I don't know why you wouldn't think he beat the best at 147... considering he beat the lineal champ, and the guy who lost to the lineal champ, but I guess I can see your argument. Who is the top challenger at 147 in your opinion?

At 154, I'm not sure who you would say is a better champion. Spinks maybe? Idk, it's hard to say, because those guys have such contrasting styles.

Anyways, I'm not arguing with you, I am actually quite curious to hear your opinion on the matter.

[squealpiggy]

Not a ****ing chance mate. You got refs in the UK like Dave Parris who reffed the Zoo fight and Cal.Mitchell and been on many shady cards as a judge. UK protects its fighters. Dave Parris should be shot...and ya'll should be embarrassed for the poor attempt @ fooling teh world.

PBF's record:
Hoya
Baldomir
Zab Judah
Sharmba Mitchell
Arturo Gatti
Henry Bruseles
DeMarcus Corley
Phillip N'dou
Jose Luis Castillo [when he was fresh]
Jesus Chavez
Carlos Hernandez
Diego Corrales
Emanuel Augustus
Angel Manfredy
Genaro Hernandez


Hattons Record:
Jose Luis Castillo [SHOT]
Juan Urango
Luis Collazo [Hatton got whipped]
Carlos Maussa
Kostya Tszyu [Shot and fought hella dirty]
Ray Oliveira [injured and shot...I know him]
Michael Stewart [who?]
Carlos Wilfredo Vilches [who?]
Dennis Holbaek Pedersen [who?]
Ben Tackie

I wont go any further....BUMS.

PBF moves up in class'...Hatton trys and gets schlacked by a no name.

Fekk off guy...quit being a nuthugger and bring something to the plate.

I'll make comments on Mayweather's opponents just as you did on Hatton's.



Hoya [old]
Baldomir [<25% KO rate]
Zab Judah [shot]
Sharmba Mitchell [Just got beat by a guy who was apparently "shot" in his next fight]
Arturo Gatti [shot - and never very good in the first place]
Henry Bruseles [who?]
DeMarcus Corley [Cotto KOed him, lost to Judah]
Phillip N'dou [who?]
Jose Luis Castillo [Castillo whipped Floyd]
Jesus Chavez
Carlos Hernandez
Diego Corrales
Emanuel Augustus [a real big win, what with Augustus' 29 losses)
Angel Manfredy
Genaro Hernandez


Hey this is a fun game! I could discredit every boxer's entire career doing this!