Mosley or Mayweather at lightweight? who wins?

[slicksouthpaw16]

It would be what we call a ''pick em fight''. which means it would be 50/50. I really don't know who would win that one. Mosley had combo's like Roy Jones Jr and Sugar ray Robinson. While Floyd had ''cat like'' reflexes and was very elusive. they probably had the same speed. If i had to bet on it, i would bet on a draw, or whoever wins, wins by split decision. what yall think?

[-Antonio-]

Styles make fights, Mosley's speed and athleticism gives Mayweather fits now, and it definitely gives him problems at Lightweight.

[-AZZA-]

unlikely fight, considering they started out they're careers at heavy.

[El Dominicano]

unlikely fight, considering they started out they're careers at heavy.

WTF! Are you talking about???

[-AZZA-]

WTF! Are you talking about???

come on then " mr. know it all " what weight did they start out at? if you say anything but heavy your mistaken...

[slicksouthpaw16]

Styles make fights, Mosley's speed and athleticism gives Mayweather fits now, and it definitely gives him problems at Lightweight.

i agree. i think Floyd can beat Shane now but i don't know if he could at lightweight. Shane was a very good fighter at lightweight but he lacks a win over a great fighter at lightweight. who has he really beat down there? If we were going by the fighter who fought better competition at lightweight, i would say Floyd has.

[Shanus]

Mosley vs Sven Ottke would be a much more realistic match up.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Styles make fights, Mosley's speed and athleticism gives Mayweather fits now, and it definitely gives him problems at Lightweight.

Doesn't that work both ways? Doesn't Mayweather's superior speed and incredible defense give Shane a look that he has never seen before?

[CASINOJOELITTLE]

It would be what we call a ''pick em fight''. which means it would be 50/50. I really don't know who would win that one. Mosley had combo's like Roy Jones Jr and Sugar ray Robinson. While Floyd had ''cat like'' reflexes and was very elusive. they probably had the same speed. If i had to bet on it, i would bet on a draw, or whoever wins, wins by split decision. what yall think?

My personal opinion and grant it pbf is my favorite and has been my favorite for years, Shane in his prime at lightweight and floyd at his prime at lightweight would make a shane UD over Prettyboy right now at welterweight would make a UD for Floyd

[-Hyperion-]

Floyd has never ever fought anyone with the speed and power of shane mosley, he would break through Floyds guard and TKO him in 11....and that guy that said floyd was faster, yeah hes faster on his feet but he doesnt have the handspeed prime mosely had...mosley is bigger, stronger, hands are faster, has a granite chin....i just dont think Floy can win it...