Where does Hopkins now stand on your P4P list?

[typeone]

To be honest!! I didnt think the fight was all that!! Watch Joe Vs Kessler..Then Compare!! Joe would smash Hopkins to bits, Joes way to quick..

[DiegoFuego]

Taylor has never lost a fight, man. How the **** can you put Hopkins above Taylor when Taylor beat him twice? You can't put Wright above Hopkins, so clearly Taylor is above both and your list is pretty ****ed up, no?

[GunStar]

JERMAIN TAYLOR??? 10 at best, top 5 is WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY to high.

I wouldnt have him in my top 10.

And no love for the marquez brothers? who not only beat two of the best men in there respective divisions, but dominated them?

Both Marquez brothers don't belong in the top 5, there is noway I can have either of those brother over Pac and Taylor. Both Taylor and Pac resume's are much better.

And i wouldnt complain if someone had Pacquiao at 6 or 7! Cuase beating up on a SHOT, completely SHOT Morales doesnt warrant a number 2 spot in my book.

Then why you have JMM at #2?? Didn't he also beat the same shot fighter in a close fight, the same shot fighter that was destroyed by Pac 4 years ago.

Its not his fault, those are fights he should have fought, and he did dominate them like he should, but to be #2 you gotta be dominated the best in the game, like the marquez brothers did

Who did JMM dominate?? He did not dominate Barrera, he won a close fight, Pac dominate Barrera 4 years ago.

[RAESAAD]

Mayweather is #1, Taylor, Pac, Hopkins and Wright should belong in everyones top 5 list, these 5 guys should be in the top 5, I don't care who's #1 or #5.

PPPPLLLLLease......give it up Gunstar.No ****ing way not even top 5.

[sonofisis]

Just because Taylor won two close, disputed decisions to Hopkins doesn't mean that he's better.. If that's the case, Hopkins gets ranked higher based on the fact that he came back and beat Winky and Taylor couldn't. He just beat Tarver also and Taylor has no one on his resume and is known only from those two close decisions and has been ****ty ever since.. If for some reason they fought again, Hopkins would easily beat him by throwing more punches because imo he's better, which is why he's ranked higher.


#1 Mayweather
#2 Manny Pacquaio
#3 Bernard Hopkins
#4 Rafael Marquez
#5 Joe Calzaghe
#6 Miguel Cotto
#7 Juan Manuel Marquez
#8 Winky Wright
#9 Jermain Taylor
#10 Ricky Hatton

[RAESAAD]

How can you have Taylor below Hopkins when Taylor beat him TWICE! You have to rank JT above BHop and, since Taylor is a #5 at best, BHop has to be at least at #6. I have them down one spot from those numbers, tho, but I'd accept the argument that they are 5 and 6, respectively. Any higher and you're kidding yourself.

Here are my new rankings:

PBF
Manny P.
JMM
Rafa Marquez
Joe Calzaghe
J.Taylor
B.Hop
W.Wright
Cotto
Hatton

Haven't done one of these in a long time, but here goes.

1) Mayweather
2) Pacquiao (now that Wright lost)
3) Taylor (beat Hopkins twice)
4) Hopkins
5) Wright
6) Cotto
7) Hatton (has two better wins than Calzaghe)
8) Calzaghe
9) Juan Manuel Marquez
10) Who cares? Rafael Marquez maybe? Whatever

**** that Taylor beat Hopkins twice ****.....Since then Hopkins has beaten Tarver and Wright......WTF has Taylor done?Got beat by Winky in many peoples eyes and went the distance with two JMW?Taylor is behind Hopkins and Winky IMO.

[iron mike tyson]

1 pbf
2 pac
3 bhop
4 r marquez
5 winky
6 calzaghe
7 hatton
8 casamoyor
9 taylor
10 cotto

[GunStar]

PPPPLLLLLease......give it up Gunstar.No ****ing way not even top 5.

Show me your top 5?

Last 5 fights, 2 wins over Hopkins, draw with Wright, win over Ouma, win over Spinks undisputed 154 champion and he's fighting Pavlik next.

Taylor belongs in the top 5, if anyone does not put Taylor in the top 5 is either biased or hater like yourself.

[sonofisis]

Show me your top 5?

Last 5 fights, 2 wins over Hopkins, draw with Wright, win over Ouma, win over Spinks undisputed 154 champion and he's fighting Pavlik next.

Taylor belongs in the top 5, if anyone does not put Taylor in the top 5 is either biased or hater like yourself.

He looked horrible against all of them and will lose to Pavlik, which is something you forgot to mention..

[GunStar]

He looked horrible against all of them and will lose to Pavlik, which is something you forgot to mention..

Well Hopkins and Wright looked horrible fighting eachother and against Taylor too, when you put great fighters against eachother 9 out of 10 times they will not look impressive against eachother. Taylor is still undefeated!

As for Pavlik, keep dreaming about it.