Who beat thier common opponents more convincingly/decisively...Cotto or Floyd?

[SpeedKillz]

What does that have to do with anything?

Don't start that reaching thing again either. You and I both know you just like Floyd so much that it affects your judgement.

i like floyd alot too, but i can admit that KOing a top fighter is more impressive than shutting him out in rounds. but that doesnt mean floyd isnt the better boxer, and it certainly has NO standing whatsoever that cotto could beat floyd, cuz he couldnt.

[Guest]

What does that have to do with anything?

Don't start that reaching thing again either. You and I both know you just like Floyd so much that it affects your judgement.

Let me spin it another way then. Mayweather beat these guys at 2-3 divisions above his starting weight class. Would Cotto be as dominant at 154 or 160 against similar opposition?

[Randall_Hopkirk]

Just about anyone can win by KO. How many fighters can win 12 round shut outs?

That guy in your sig who you oh so dislike, does it often

[Guest]

i like floyd alot too, but i can admit that KOing a top fighter is more impressive than shutting him out in rounds. but that doesnt mean floyd isnt the better boxer, and it certainly has NO standing whatsoever that cotto could beat floyd, cuz he couldnt.

I don't consider it more impressive because they don't have equal power. If Mayweather had Cotto's power, those fights don't last 4 rounds...

[robjr]

cotto no doubt.

[SpeedKillz]

That guy in your sig who you oh so dislike.

really? against who?

[Run]

Let me spin it another way then. Mayweather beat these guys at 2-3 divisions above his starting weight class. Would Cotto be as dominant at 154 or 160 against similar opposition?

i like floyd alot too, but i can admit that KOing a top fighter is more impressive than shutting him out in rounds. but that doesnt mean floyd isnt the better boxer, and it certainly has NO standing whatsoever that cotto could beat floyd, cuz he couldnt.

Guys please quit. It's sad.

I never for once questioned Floyd as a fighter because he's much better than Cotto is. This wasn't a "Who's more capable" or "Who's a better fighter" it's a ****ing poll asking a simple question that a blind ****** could answer correctly.



Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

[Guest]

That guy in your sig who you oh so dislike.

Calzaghe's win over Lacy (12 round shut out) is more impressive than Cotto knocking out average fighters...

[SpeedKillz]

I don't consider it more impressive because they don't have equal power. If Mayweather had Cotto's power, those fights don't last 4 rounds...

very very true. p4p cotto doesnt hold a handle to floyd. cotto beat those guys more convincingly as a puncher, floyd beat them more convincingly as a boxer, but i would rather watch mayweather fight than cotto any day of the week.

[deevel79]

Guys please quit. It's sad.

I never for once questioned Floyd as a fighter because he's much better than Cotto is. This wasn't a "Who's more capable" or "Who's a better fighter" it's a ****ing poll asking a simple question that a blind ****** could answer correctly.

Exactly!....Thank you. The Floydboys are trying to put spin on the question now because the answer doesnt favor Floyd!