If Floyd was not American, would he still be considered P4P #1

[wmute]

he should, but he would not because there is bias pro-american fighters

[eazy_mas]

Well Then If you are doing it on Skill alone.. Arguably.. Joe Calzaghe is a Skilled as Floyd Mayweather.. he can Dominate a STIFF Slugger Just as well as Floyd and Win a 120-108 Descion .. His Resume is Comprable.. A few genuine Threats And mostly Stiffs... Why Has Joe C never been P4P#1 ?

I could name a few others Who are Just as Dominant beating up 35 year olds and/or Stiffs.. who never made P4P#1 before..
Mostly they have being NON American In common

because he has two famous contender knowen to public Eubank and Lacy.

he got alot of good contender and ex-champions as Robin Reid , Omar Shieka and Baron. but it cant be compared with Floyd contedners, ex-champion and chmapions wins and not to mention some future hOF

[Don Johnson]

There's no way in hell he'd be even in the top 5. Judges hate foreigners, especially if a belt is at stake.

[TheEvilSaint]

probly. american's are dumb and biased though. so i guess we'll never know.