The scoring was BS

[ELPacman]

It was 9 rounds to 3, every round being clear as day to me to score. Check out the judges' resumes. Two of them had NO NOTABLE FIGHTS under their belts. Not too bad for a first time out I guess.

I was actually really worried about that. I think the reason HBO did that was so they could blame a close decision win to Margarito on the fact that they were unexperienced judges. I really think a lot was put in for Margarito to win to setup a Cotto-margarito fight. I even felt like ref, Lou Morette or whatever his name was, was being annoying about telling Williams to stop holding. He's a tall guy and was using it strategically. As soon as he gave Williams 1 last warning, it took Williams completely outta his game and he was getting tagged a lot more. I swear, if Williams was KOed at that point, it woulda been the ref's fault!

[English Lion]

williams threw too many punches and was far more aggressive thank margirito, williams deserved his win

[ELPacman]

williams threw too many punches and was far more aggressive thank margirito, williams deserved his win

Exactly. I was thinking, if Williams doesn't win it after doing what he did, wtf does it take to win then?

[Ace Rockolla]

I also had it 8-4 for Williams, but you gave the 11th round to Williams?

Haha, my bad. 6,7,8, and 11 to Margarito.

[Stickman]

Dominating is too strong a word. Winning the rounds comfortably, I'll buy. Dominating is something I reserve for multiple KD's, constantly catching a guy with the same shot over and over and over (much like Gatti's fight went), and ending either in a TKO, or a near shutout.

I didn't score it on paper, but I think I gave Margarito 4, don't recall for sure. That's not a near shutout, just a real comfortable win, which is what he deserved. What I don't get is that 2 judges would've ended the fight with a draw if A.M. had won the 12th on their cards? Now that is ****ing ******.