Is Shane Mosley Past His Prime?

[baya]

in potential fights with mayweather and cotto, he gets beat.

hatton becomes shane's victim, however. that doesn't make him upper-echelon elite though.

shane's been past his prime, he used to be better than floyd IMO. he is no where near floyd now.

[niceguy45]

in my opinion is the final chapter of his prime career maybe this year

[robjr]

1st of all.. mosley offered maywether 15 million. and hatton offered him 10 million.. mayweather is tkaing less money for the easier fight end of story.. And its cool some yall think Floyd is better than Shane, but can one of you tell Floyd that??? Cause its obvious he isnt as confident with the bogus excuses he makes... Floyd wants to hold the p4p title with his life... sad..

[Left2body]

He is By no means SHOT... and so naturally talented that even past his prime.. he is an upper echlon fighter.. BUT past his PRIME he is...

EDIT I cant vote on your Poll.. due the questions as always not being subjective enough.. I would have voted for a LIttle past his prime..

Agree with you 100%. While no longer in his prime he is still arguably the #1 guy and easily top 3 in the toughest deepest division in boxing today.

[DiegoFuego]

All I can say is if he's past it, it's pretty incredible he was able to win every round against a guy that had Hatton in trouble. Speaks worlds about Mosley or means Hatton is crap.

He's not that far past his best, ladies and gents. Look at his rematch with Vargas (I know, it's Vargas), but Mosley was spectacular.

[squealpiggy]

Mosley's prime was at 147 the first time. He's good but is past his prime a little and at 35 any elite fighter who takes him on can expect criticism for picking on a past-prime fighter.

[-Antonio-]

He is By no means SHOT... and so naturally talented that even past his prime.. he is an upper echlon fighter.. BUT past his PRIME he is...

EDIT I cant vote on your Poll.. due the questions as always not being subjective enough.. I would have voted for a LIttle past his prime..

This is how I see it as well.

[Tmb04]

He aint "Past" his prime yet. He still has a few more fights left in him before he's past his prime though. But I like Mosley though, I really hope he gets another chance at a title before retiring preferably Mayweather though.

[Sttuddahboy619]

The fight with Collazo proved that he wasn't past his prime!

[ThaHorseman]

Of course Mosley is past his prime. He is still a decent fighter, but not nearly as good as people like to give him credit for. He's still solid in all areas, but he would struggle with any top fighters at 147 or 154.