Who has the better resume,Winky or Pacquiao?

[-EX-]

Who do you think has the better resume Winky Wright or Manny Pacquiao?
Notable Winky Wright Wins
Ike Quartey
Shane Mosley (twice)
Felix Trinidad
http://www.boxrec.com/boxer_display.php?boxer_id=003600

Manny Pacquiao

Erik Morales (twice)
Jorge Solis
Oscar Larios
Marco Antonio Barrera
https://www.boxrec.com/boxer_display...oxer_id=006129

Both guys are considered #2 on the pound for pound list by different people.

[DLT]

You still forgot some good ones like a prime Vargas, and the Hopkins fight is happening. You also forgot JMM for Pac. I like Winky's resume better

[-EX-]

I really put down the wins. The Marquez fight was a draw I believe. Winky wasn't given the win against Vargas(although I hear he deserved it). That's why I didn't put down Jermain Taylor.

[Slotff]

I think Pac, but also man Winky didn't beat JCV, he got beaten up and dropped five times.

[wolfgang]

winky by far I think winky should be p4p number one, I think pac best wins are against a old morals and barrera. Most people think he lost to marquez and he lost to morals in the first fight. Plus i think he winky beat talyor in a close fight and was robbed against a prime vargas.

[DLT]

Ive always asked what did Pac due to be universaly the #2 P4P guy in the world and alot of places he's #1. I dont mean it like he hasnt done anything, I mean it like what the hell did Winky do to get leap frogged? He's taking on all the top guys and is clearly winning. Even against Taylor most think he won but a draw still isnt bad. I dont even think Pac should be over Hopkins. Hopkins just murdered Tarver and alot of people think he won both times against a young Taylor.

[Bogler]

winky by far I think winky should be p4p number one, I think pac best wins are against a old morals and barrera. Most people think he lost to marquez and he lost to morals in the first fight. Plus i think he winky beat talyor in a close fight and was robbed against a prime vargas.

old barrera? he strung up 6 straight wins, two over rocky after the loss to pac and ur calling him old? he became old because of pac. not even JMM 4yrs after could put down MAB. same could be said of morales, it was less than a year only since he edged pac. and odds were he would win in the rematch.

and no, not most ppl think he lost to marquez, only most latinos or mexicans probably, all of hbo that night and critics had pac winning. jmm may have deserved the draw by virtue of his great comeback PLUS a scoring error, but he definitely NOT clearly won.

[amagnin]

I'm not going to downplay any of Pac's big wins. He beat MAB brutally and he won 2/3 against Erik Morales. Both have to be considered some of the best of our era at those weights. On the other hand Winky has beaten Shane Mosley (twice); Felix Trinidad (slightly past his prime); and imo won the MW championship. Considering that Winky has had to fight to get most of these fights. I consider his resume slightly superior.

[wolfgang]

I thought Mab beat MW in there fight but and Ive always thought mab was better then morals the problem mab hes been fighter in his natural weight class morals has been draining himself to make that weight for awile. Rocky has never beat a world class fighter. I dont get this oscar is old hasnt been close to the wars that mab been but hes old maybe not in age but when he fought manny it was his 62 fight.