Castillo vs Mayweather 1

[Tysonisgod]

I'm goin to go and watch Floyd vs Castillio 1 and 2, cos they are the next to fights on my dvd and i just wanted to have a quick post to say....for those who think floyd lost this fight, can you post how you scored it, but not like the final score, i mean round for round who u gave it to and why etc etc, and i will give a full scorecard 2moro morning when i get up before trainin, or when i get back in from training thanks guy

[DiegoFuego]

GREAT IDEA! This gets argued so much that I have saved my scorecard.

10-9 Mayweather
10-9 Mayweather
10-9 Mayweather
10-9 Mayweather

I don't think these first 4 are debatable and am not willing to listen to people who scored them for Castillo. Mayweather repeatedly tags him with his jab and Castillo hits nothing but arms.

At this point, you gotta believe there's no way Floyd can lose unless he loses points or gets knocked down.

10-9 Mayweather
10-9 Castillo
10-9 Castillo
10-8 Mayweather

Castillo loses a point for hitting on the break in a round he is losing. At this point, he needs at least one 10-8 round to get a draw.

10-9 Castillo
9-9 even

Mayweather loses a point in a round he is winning for using his elbow, which, admittedly, is something he gets away with every fight, but not on this night.

10-9 Castillo
10-9 Castillo

Castillo finishes strong to take the last 2 rounds, but it isn't enough.

114-112

As you can see, Castillo finished strong, which is how most people remember fights and ONLY choose to remember that. In this fight, it was the first part of the fight that was key. Close fight, but Mayweather won it by putting in the work early. I'm still amazed he could beat Castillo with one hand, but he did. I had the rematch 9 rounds to 3.

[DiegoFuego]

Everyone on the entire forum who ever discusses this fight should be required to post a similar synopsis just so we know who knows boxing and who is full of ****.

[Tysonisgod]

just watched first 4 rounds, there is no way anyone could possibly score it anyother way apart from for floyd....i wonder how many floyd "haters" are gonna come on this post lol this is a great idea if i do say so myself lol

[DiegoFuego]

It's a terrific idea and I want someone to admit to scoring any of the first 4 for Castillo just so we know who to put on permanent ignore

[Slotff]

Mayweather: 1,2,3*,4,8
Castillo: 3*,5,6,7,8,10,11,12

Round 3 could go either way.

I like Mayweather equally as Castillo, but NO way he won that.

[deliveryman]

10-9 Mayweather
10-9 Mayweather
10-9 Mayweather
10-9 Mayweather
10-9 Mayweather
10-9 Castillo
10-9 Castillo
9-9 Even *Scored the round for Castillo -1 for the point deduction
10-9 Mayweather
10-8 Castillo *Point taken from Mayweather for elbowing
10-9 Mayweather
10-9 Castillo

Score: 114-112 for Mayweather.

I made a thread a while ago, posting a video of the entire fight and a break down after each round.

[DiegoFuego]

We got the same score. Nice.

The main reason you can tell most people didn't actually break it down round by round is the fact that people who say Castillo won claim he won big while rational people post a close scorecard that usually has Mayweather as the winner. I wouldn't care if I saw someone score it even or to Castillo by a point, but beyond that, it starts getting absurd. It was close.

[EliteSoldier]

You both have the same score because one of you copied off the other. Probably from another topic on the same subject.

[DiegoFuego]

You both have the same score because one of you copied each other.

Nice try. We didn't score the same rounds the same. You are the weakest link. Goodbye.

While we're at it, post your scorecard. I'd LOVE to see that joke of a card posted here if you have the guts.