How Would A RJ, Toney, Holyfield Matchup Play Out At 190?

[DLT]

Tell me how these matchups wouldve played out at Cruiserweight if they fought eachother. Tell me RJ vs Toney, RJ vs Evander, Evander vs Toney.

Its a hard question because RJ never fought there but he was a beast at 175 and he did look great against Ruiz at HW so its not crazy to think he wouldve looked good at 190 atleast for a few fights.

I also want you to think of this as it is Toney "at his best", in shape and motivated. Ofcourse Im speaking of a Prime Evander

[GEOFFHAYES]

Toney (pre-Jones) and Jones were at their best at 168

But anyway, I think Toney can run Jones fairly close

Evander shakes them both up

[EliteSoldier]

I don't think toney could ever be 190 again... He likes to eat too much. I think he choose food over boxing.

[Zerwas1]

Jones beats Toney, anywhere, anytime, because he knows how. Toneys footwork can't compete with Jones style.

Holyfield is stylewise a nightmare for Jones, so I give him the edge there. He's just much more familiar with this weight.

Holyfield vs Toney prime vs prime both on steroids^^ I think Holyfield takes it

[-Antonio-]

I think Toney would fight a closer fight with RJJ, but its just a style mismatch for him. RJJ would move and potshot Toney all night, not allowing him to counter or set up for anything. I think Toney has the style to cause even a prime Holyfield trouble, but he would probably beat him on the cards. RJJ wouldnt have a chance against Holy. No way. Holyfield was a machine at Cruiserweight. I dont see anyone beating him.

[GreatestIam]

well i think Toney v Jones Jr would play out somewhat the same but i dont know cuz Toney is the embodiment of "time does the body good" then bad then well look at him now! as for Jones Jr V Holyfield damn that would have been a classic a slugger with skill against skill and speed i honestly would favor Jones Jr because he had speed and very underrated power, i think he would jab Holyfield to death and even slug with him 1 thing ive noticed about holy with fast guys who try to throw is he gets caught but he never really fought as fast a guy as Jones Jr in his prime, id say Jr by 12 rd tko......

As for Hol V Toney again it would be classic but i think Toney is to wise but would ultimatley lose a 12 rd decision