Better Legacy: Calzaghe or Ottke?

[jaws]

Calzaghe by a mile, Ottke is basura

[Technical_Skill]

On paper, Ottke, without a doubt,

In reality, calzaghe.

[robjr]

both there resume's put me into a coma. not to mention some contraversial ****..

[.Mik.]

There really isnt any controversy about Calzaghe's resume.

[Guest]

There really isnt any controversy about Calzaghe's resume.

Go watch the Robin Reid fight...

[.Mik.]

I've watched it. I'm not entirely sure that you have.

Some could say that Reid won the fight (Reid certainly didnt). Most would admit that he didnt. So one close call that MAY have gone either way can hardly be considered a 'controversial decision', especially when Reid was the hometown fighter.

Thats like someone narrowly defeating Ottke in Germany, getting the decision and it then their career being put under scrutiny for being 'controversial'.

[BROOKLYN CESAR]

I think the two of them were scared to fight the best!!! Which is why they didnt fight each other!!! Not that theyre the best!!! Kessler will hammer joe and wouldve hammered ottke too!!! But Joe is my pick out of the two!!!

[robjr]

yep the reid fight..