What Is Your Top 10 P4P?

[Technical_Skill]

1. R.Marquez
2. M.Pacquiao
3. B.Hopkins
4. W.Wright
5. F.Mayweather
6. J.M.Marquez
7. J.L.Castillo
8. R.Hatton
9. J.Casamayor
10.J.Diaz

....................................

What do you say about this?

lol.

[Tha_Greatest]

....................................

What do you say about this?

lol.

its just an opinion, im sorry if its not to your expectations.I put Casamayor in cause he beat Corrales twice. He is a current WBC champ and many people believe he beat Freitas and J.L.Castillo. Hes never beeen out of a fight so. Aghhh, to much to answer, if i have to go fighter by fighter, what do you base your top 10

[Technical_Skill]

its just an opinion, im sorry if its not to your expectations.I put Casamayor in cause he beat Corrales twice. He is a current WBC champ and many people believe he beat Freitas and J.L.Castillo. Hes never beeen out of a fight so. Aghhh, to much to answer, if i have to go fighter by fighter, what do you base your top 10

I judge pound 4 pound by deciding who are best fighters in the world if the attributes were not affected by weight.

Nothing else, thats what pound for pound means (ive explained this in so many threads, lol)

I dont think you can competantly list these pound 4 pound fighters 1-10, i wouldnt even try.(certainly not right now)

All i know is Mayweather is the best, Winky/Hopkins, Pacquiao would be in my list, everyone else, im not sure about,

No i dont think ricky hatton is the 8th best fighter in the world when weight doesnt affect a fighters attributes.

[Tha_Greatest]

I judge pound 4 pound by deciding who are best fighters in the world if the attributes were not affected by weight.

Nothing else, thats what pound for pound means (ive explained this in so many threads, lol)

I dont think you can competantly list these pound 4 pound fighters 1-10, i wouldnt even try.(certainly not right now)

All i know is Mayweather is the best, Winky/Hopkins, Pacquiao would be in my list, everyone else, im not sure about,

No i dont think ricky hatton is the 8th best fighter in the world when weight doesnt affect a fighters attributes.

I know about that, If you are a Mayweather fan and are wondering why he aint on #1 on my list, its his lack of elite style fights, only 3 Corrales,Castillo, DeLa Hoya , I thought he lost to Castillo the 1st fight and he barely beat a old De La Hoya, way out of prime, before DLH, he was my #1 but i thought the fight with Oscar couldve gone either way, so he went down on my list,

[Technical_Skill]

I know about that, If you are a Mayweather fan and are wondering why he aint on #1 on my list, its his lack of elite style fights, only 3 Corrales,Castillo, DeLa Hoya , I thought he lost to Castillo the 1st fight and he barely beat a old De La Hoya, way out of prime, before DLH, he was my #1 but i thought the fight with Oscar couldve gone either way, so he went down on my list,

Dude its cool, its your list, mayweather at 5 didnt bother me, i was more reffering to no Jermaine Taylor and Hatton above hopkins.

But i was just messing, its your list, you dont have to justify it to me.

[Tha_Greatest]

Dude its cool, its your list, mayweather at 5 didnt bother me, i was more reffering to no Jermaine Taylor and Hatton above hopkins.

But i was just messing, its your list, you dont have to justify it to me.

Jermain Taylor

Hes close to top 10 if i was to make a longer list, I believe if he wouldve gotten a solid victory vs hopkins or wright, he definitely is in but who really is his solid defining performance against? Corey Spinks.

Think about it

[-EX-]

With Floyd still active

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr
I don't give a damn who's second and after that. I only care about who's #1

With Floyd not active
1. Winky Wright
I will move Winky down if he loses to Bernard.

[Technical_Skill]

Jermain Taylor

Hes close to top 10 if i was to make a longer list, I believe if he wouldve gotten a solid victory vs hopkins or wright, he definitely is in but who really is his solid defining performance against? Corey Spinks.

Think about it

I did think about it, i thought about how youve got mayweather at 5 for not fighting big enough names,

But you havent got taylor in there at all whose last 5 fights are spinks, wright, ouma and hopkins x2.

Then i think about how you got hatton in there, whose only fought one big name so far in his carrer.

[Shanus]

With Floyd still active

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr
I don't give a damn who's second and after that. I only care about who's #1

With Floyd not active
1. Winky Wright
I will move Winky down if he loses to Bernard.

So when Floyd retires you'll change your name to Pacfan90 or Winkyfan90?

You're not a boxing fan, you're a glory supporter.

[Tha_Greatest]

I did think about it, i thought about how youve got mayweather at 5 for not fighting big enough names,

But you havent got taylor in there at all whose last 5 fights are spinks, wright, ouma and hopkins x2.

Then i think about how you got hatton in there, whose only fought one big name so far in his carrer.

The Taylor wins vs hopkins werent solid, i thought he lost both of them and the Wright draw wasnt solid either, Kassim Ouma isnt a big name, Hes a quality win but he is not a elite win, I dont even like Hatton but hes a champ, undefeated , hes beaten Tsyzu solidly, so even though i hate Hatton, i put him in their