Pound 4 Pound Question for you all

[ICEMAN JOHN SCULLY]

http://icemanjohnscully.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=107

[jack_the_rippuh]

In no particular order:

Pacquiao
Calzaghe
Wright
Hopkins
J.Marquez
R.Marquez
Diaz
Taylor
Cotto
Barrera

[bishop2006]

In no particular order -
Mayweather
Wright
Pacman
R.Marquez
J.Marquez
Hopkins
Juan Diaz
Mosley
Calzaghe
Barrera

[Tysonisgod]

i dont get this, Manny Pac is prob on everyone list because he is fun to watch, because you know, win or lose you are gonna see some blood and some knock downs, but skill level is very low if you put him against mayweather, mosley, bhop and de la hoya, even morales and barrera hav better skill than him..
Calzaghe - The guy has never impressed me, i was a fan and still kinda am, but i hate watchin his fights now,he does throw slaps just like jeff lacy says,hard slaps at that lol but he throws alot of wild shots and because of the lacy masterpeice people think he is amazing boxers, Wrights shut up over Tito wass much more impressive a guy like Wright should be up there but shouldnt be up there to, i mean he whoops shane then fought him again then WHOOPS titos ass then has a draw with Taylor, and if Taylor wasnt put at the top after beatin the top p4p then what makes Winky so high up there, and since hopkins is on this, why dont we talk about him, he done great in last few years and he should still be in the top 5 pound for pound, J.Marquez hasnt done anything to prove he should be on the list apart from M.A.B IMO i think pac beat him in the fight and i dont think M.A.B deserved to lose against him. Diaz Taylor Cotto shouldnt be on anyones list, because basicly there not that good, diaz is a good lil fighter, taylors 3 biggest fights were all close fights and was a draw in last one, and Cotto? maybe in about 3 years when hes developed into a real fighter and can learn to cover up a bit..hope Zab whoops that ass

[THE REAL NINJA]

Floyd Mayweather Jr
2 Winky Wright
3 Bernard Hopkins
4 Jermain Taylor
5 Manny Pacquiao
6 Shane Mosley
7 R.Marquez
8 Joe Calzaghe
9 Ricky Hatton
10 Juan Manuel Marquez

..10th place subs .............
De La Hoya
Cotto


BOXREC
...........
Floyd Mayweather Jr Light Middleweight
2 Rafael Marquez Super Bantamweight
3 Jermain Taylor Middleweight
4 Bernard Hopkins Light Heavyweight
5 Ronald Wright Middleweight
6 Shane Mosley Welterweight
7 Manny Pacquiao Super Featherweight
8 Ricky Hatton Light Welterweight
9 Chris John Featherweight
10 Joe Calzaghe Super Middleweight
11 Pongsaklek Wonjongkam Flyweight
12 Vic Darchinyan

[amagnin]

No particular order...
Mayweather
Wright
Hopkins
Calzaghe
JM Marquez
R. Marquez
Pacquiao
Taylor
J. Diaz
Guzman or Cotto

[sweet_science_1]

In no order:

Taylor
B-Hop
Wright
Marquez
Pac-Man
Calzaghe
Hatton
Cotto
Kessler
De La Hoya

[JOM'S]

P4P

if weight and size is not a factor PBF will box Vitali's head off...
if weight and size is not a factor PAC wil KTFO Vitali ...

[EliteSoldier]

P4P

if weight and size is not a factor PBF will box Vitali's head off...
if weight and size is not a factor PAC wil KTFO Vitali ...

No and No to both

[JOM'S]

No and No to both

lol how can you say that ??? we are talking mythical p4p here...

mayweather have shown he can outbox all the guys he faced from 130 to 154, and if size and weight is a not a factor he is a better boxer than vitali...

Pacman has KOs from 108 to 130 if everthing remaining constant and pac and vitali are the same size, vitali will get koed...

this mythical bro! not reality so i can choose who beats who!! lol