Where is Ricky Hatton in your P4P?

[Shanus]

If you have him less than 10-12 you're a clown.

I have him at spot 9-10 or so right now.

[.Mik.]

Low top 10 until he gets beat or until he fights another P4P fighter.


Again...if the results of your poll are a general consensus that he is a top 10 P4P fighter, will you accept it, or will you discredit it?

[jcarr71]

He's either at the very back end of the top ten or just outside of it. I could understand him anywhere from 8-12, no higher and no lower.

[EliteSoldier]

If he fought and beat mayweather, is he number 1?

[Technical_Skill]

If he fought and beat mayweather, is he number 1?

Offically yes.

In my eyes, i think i can think of 10 more skilled fighters than Hatton if their attributes are not affected by weight.

[The Monk]

I voted top 20, he is about 11 or 12 in my list.

[Shanus]

If he fought and beat mayweather, is he number 1?

Negative, top 3.

[.Mik.]

If he fought and beat mayweather, is he number 1?

To be fair...yes, he probably is. Depends on the manner of his victory though really.

[Shanus]

Offically yes.

In my eyes, i think i can think of 10 more skilled fighters than Hatton if their attributes are not affected by weight.

But skill isn't the be all and end all of boxing, even though I expect you to disagree.

[Technical_Skill]

But skill isn't the be all and end all of boxing, even though I expect you to disagree.

You know i judge Pound 4 Pound by its true meaning.

The best fighters in the world when the attributes are not affected by weight.

Under this definition, im not sure Hatton is top 10.

Offically, yes, he probably is.