With PBF at 154, Who is Now the Best Welterweight?

[Guest]

Mosley
Margarito
Cotto
Clottey
Cintron
Judah
Collazo
Baldomir
Williams

Mosley's the only fighter on the list who has completely dominated another top 10 welterweight in Collazo, whom I'd edge over Cintron & have a real chance against Cotto.
Added to his previous top level experience makes him a lock on the top spot.

Collazo is overrated. I would have been more impressed if Mosley had beaten Cintron the same way...

[DiegoFuego]

Mosley and Cotto are on a different level than the rest of those guys, but it's tough to pick between Mosley and Cotto and tough to pick one out of the rest of them as a standout. Good division no doubt.

[yrrej]

Hasn't anybody seen Clottey lately?

[-EX-]

Yeah Clottey did whoop Corrales' ass. He looked good. He deserves a shot against another good welterweight.

[Guest]

Hasn't anybody seen Clottey lately?

He should be the WBO champion. I think he can hang with anyone at welterweight...