OVERTURN Boxing's Worst Descisions

[-Hyperion-]

Like I said close BUT CLEAR. I dont like these It could have gone either way ****. Either its a clear draw or someone won. Thread says nothing about robberies.

exactly, couldve gone either way is ****ing bull****

[mikefromstu]

Sam Garr/Matt Vanda.

That was the wost scoring that I have EVER seen. Garr clearly won 8 if not 9 rounds and Vanda won a SD. It was sick.

[{BrownBomber}]

Forgot to mention

Chavez-Whittaker / Chaves had nothing for Pee Pee that night.

[Easy-E]

Robberies
Chavez/Whitaker
Holy/Lewis
Ottke/Mitchell
Ottke/Brewer
Ottke/Reid
Burton/Augustus

Close fights but result went the wrong way
Benn/Eubank II
Watson/Eubank
Hernandez/Pacquiao
Holmes/Spinks II
Holmes/Witherspoon
Ali/Shavers
Urango/Rabah

That was a ****ing robbery.

[Gio]

Oscar vs Tito fight.

[Addison]

Robberies
Chavez/Whitaker
Holy/Lewis
Ottke/Mitchell
Ottke/Brewer
Ottke/Reid
Burton/Augustus

Close fights but result went the wrong way
Benn/Eubank II
Watson/Eubank
Hernandez/Pacquiao
Holmes/Spinks II
Holmes/Witherspoon
Ali/Shavers
Urango/Rabah

Nice.

[Addison]

Maybe I interpret robberies differently. You guys have the DLH-Mosley fight up there?

Now, that fight was close. And that's the point. It was close, not ones sided or anything. A robbery is like, when a clear winner is stripped of a win. You should forget the scorecards. It's about who won?

DLH was robbed against Tito, for example. It was a clear win on Oscar's part.

But in the second Mosley fight, it was up for grabs. No way was it a robbery, it was too close.

Same thing for Mayweather-JLC I.

I hear what you're saying but professional judges should be held to a higher standard.

When they **** up fights 75% of the public agrees on I think we have a problem..

[K-Nine]

K-nine was robbed against Forbes.

Emanuel Augustus was wildly and blatantly robbed on several occasion. I still can't forget the first Burton fight. A travesty, it was.

[oldgringo]

Augustus/Burton was pathetic, Rabah/Urango, Whitaker/Ramirez I, Morales/Barrera II...all decisions which should have gone the other way.

[Hitman932]

Augustus/Burton was pathetic, Rabah/Urango, Whitaker/Ramirez I, Morales/Barrera II...all decisions which should have gone the other way.

i was going to mention the ben rabah fight...

i remember scoring it the same as teddy atlas something like 117-111 or 116-112 for ben rabah...

i read an account though from another website by a guy who writes very honest and insightful articles and he sat ringside at the fight and said that it was obvious from rabahs language that even the slightest punches urango landed were hurting him... he said he had scored the fight a draw...

so i think based on that im gonna remove it from my "outright robbery" list and move in down to "decision to wrong guy"

i actually bet on urango to win by decision that night cause i knew it was a hometown fight and he was like 6.5-1 to pull a decision.... i thought my money was flushed down the toilet..

when they announced the decision it was a bizarre mix of happiness and disgust