Extended p4p List

[The Raging Bull]

1.) Floyd Mayweather Jr
2.) Manny Pacquiao
3.) Ronald Wright
4.) Rafael Marquez
5.) Joe Calzaghe
6.) Marco Antonio Barrera
7.) Jermain Taylor
8.) Bernard Hopkins
9.) Ricky Hatton
10.) Jose Luis Castillo
11.) Shane Mosley
12.) Miguel Cotto
13.) Jorge Arce
14.) Joel Casamayor
15.) Vic Darchinyan
16.) Edison Miranda
17.) Ivan Calderon
18.) Juan Manuel Marquez
19.) Chad Dawson
20.) Arthur Abraham

[oldgringo]

BTW having Chad Dawson in your top 15/20 is ridiculous.

Not as ridiculous as you putting Chris John in yours, but what have you...

Dawson just impressively beat (and largely dominated) two very good fighters in Eric Harding and Tomasz Adamek. He has also stopped Ian Gardner and the old vet Carl Daniels. He's one of the best young fighters in the world right now.

What do we know about John...? He (by many accounts) controversially beat Juan Manuel Marquez in his own backyard. I think everyone could use more information on this kid before saying he's one of the 20 best fighters in the world.

[Easy-E]

That's pretty good to get 20 fighters together, it's not neccessarily easy to make them in my opininion only I would have Calzaghe in Wright's slot, Darchinyan higher, Pavlik somewhere in the top 20, Cotto somewhere in the top 10, Mosely higher, probably Hatton lower.

I think I agree with your top 3.

What has Joe done to make himself top 5 p4p in the sport???
What p4p fighters has he faced and beaten??

[borikua]

I never do p4p lists, but *** it...

1. Pacquiao
2. Floyd
3. Taylor
4. Wright
5. Hopkins
6. Rafa
7. Barrera
8. Mosley
9. JMM
10. Calderon
11. JLC
12. Cotto

[oldgringo]

New listing:

1.) Floyd Mayweather Jr
2.) Manny Pacquiao
3.) Rafael Marquez
4.) Ronald Wright
5.) Joe Calzaghe
6.) Jermain Taylor
7.) Bernard Hopkins
8.) Juan Manuel Marquez
9.) Marco Antonio Barrera
10.) Ricky Hatton
11.) Jorge Arce
12.) Jose Luis Castillo
13.) Miguel Cotto
14.) Shane Mosley
15.) Joel Casamayor
16.) Chad Dawson
17.) Ivan Calderon
18.) Vic Darchinyan
19.) Edison Miranda
20.) Arthur Abraham

Marquez cracks the top ten, Barrera down 3 slots.

[oldgringo]

Floyd Mayweather Jr
Manny Pacquiao
Rafael Marquez
Ronald Wright
Joe Calzaghe
Jermain Taylor
Bernard Hopkins
Juan Manuel Marquez
Marco Antonio Barrera
Ricky Hatton
Jose Luis Castillo
Shane Mosley
Miguel Cotto
Joel Casamayor
Mikkel Kessler
Vic Darchinyan
Chad Dawson
Ivan Calderon
Edison Miranda
Oscar De La Hoya

New list. Arce out....snuck De La Hoya in for good measure.

[The Fix]

Floyd Mayweather Jr
Manny Pacquiao
Rafael Marquez
Ronald Wright
Joe Calzaghe
Jermain Taylor
Bernard Hopkins
Juan Manuel Marquez
Marco Antonio Barrera
Ricky Hatton
Jose Luis Castillo
Shane Mosley
Miguel Cotto
Joel Casamayor
Vic Darchinyan
Chad Dawson
Ivan Calderon
Edison Miranda
Arthur Abraham
Oscar De La Hoya

New list. Arce out....snuck De La Hoya in for good measure.

hey, stop bringing old threads.... jerk. anyway when zab beats cotto, is he in your top 10?

[bengidaro]

I got to agree with you on this one I think Manny Pacquiao is a better P4P fighter than Mayweather.

[Slotff]

1. Floyd Mayweather, Jr.
2. Joe Calzaghe
3. Manny Pacquiao
4. Rafael Marquez
5. Oscar de la Hoya
6. Jose Luis Castillo
7. Juan Manuel Marquez
8. Wladimir Klitschko
9. Bernard Hopkins
10. Winky Wright
11. Jermain Taylor
12. Joan Guzman
13. Mikkel Kessler
14. Glenn Johnson
15. Miguel Cotto
16. Marco Antonio Barrera
17. Acelino Freitas
18. Carlos Baldomir
19. Ricky Hatton
20. Edison Miranda
21. Edwin Valero
22. Antonio Tarver
23. Joshua Clottey
24. Felix Sturm
25. Chris Byrd

Yeah...

[Rudyo]

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2. Winky Wright
3. Manny Pacquiao
4. Rafeal Marquez
5. Joe Calzaghe
6. Juan Manuel Marquez
7. Bernard Hopkins
8. Marco Antonio Barrera
9. Joel Casamayor
10. Jose Luis Castillo
11. Shane Mosley
12. Miguel Cotto
13. Ricky Hatton
14. Jermain Taylor
15. Chad Dawson
16. Ivan Calderon
17. Cristian Mijares
18. Oscar De La Hoya
19. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam
20. Juan Diaz