Who you really think can beat Calzaghe?

[Bambicolors]

I think Jermain Taylor can't beat Calzaghe...

[PATO 1]

Winky
B-Hop
Jermain Taylor
Mikkel Kessler
Antonio Tarver

[The Noose]

His age, and his ringware.

[The Wire]

Winky
B-Hop
Jermain Taylor
Mikkel Kessler
Antonio Tarver

If you mean all those would stand a chance then fair enough, but I would pick Calzaghe as favourite against all of those except maybe Hopkins and Taylor.

[The Wire]

actually no, i would pick calzaghe as favourite in those two as well

[tito yuca]

Winky
B-Hop
Jermain Taylor
Mikkel Kessler
Antonio Tarver

No way in hell Tarver comes close to beating Calzaghe now. He threw, what, 20 punches in the whole Hopkins fight?

[Mike_R]

Bernard Hopkins
Jermaine Taylor
Winky Wright (maybe, depends on how he looks at the bigger weights)
Mikkel Kessler (wouldn't favor him but he deserves the damn fight)

[kayjay]

Winky
B-Hop
Jermain Taylor
Mikkel Kessler
Antonio Tarver

Winky : Joe is too big (should be fighting at 175), powerful, and active
b-Hop : the toughest fight on this list, but Joe would probably outwork him
Taylor : power could create problems but I think Calzaghe would make him miss too much
Kessler: presents a problem, but we haven't seen this guy depart from his jab-right "'Cause I'm bigger and faster and stronger." How much does the kid have in his arsenal, really?
Tarver : not a chance


I would pick Joe over these five, without worry or hesitation.

But what the hell do I know?

[bluemax]

I think the only interesting fight out of all that have been mentioned would be Calzaghe against Jermain Taylor. I still think Taylor lost against Winky and also in the second Hopkins fight but he has raw talent. If that talent can be harnessed and he improves I think he's going to only get better. He's young, strong and fast. Calzaghe would still be my favorite in the fight but I think Jermain is the only one who would have a reasonable chance of beating him if he comes with his A game.

[Tuggers1986]

I think Calzaghe would beat all 5 of those with B Hop and Taylor giving him the most trouble.